For me, this game mode has to have all of those components (roster building, defense/offense strategy and tactical execution). However two of those components (which is the actual playing of the game) are taken away when the outcome is predetermined.
You do realize that you can have fun both by building roster and by playing out the actual GAC, right? One doesn't rule out the other.
You do realize that all the elements you request are still there when you have the stronger roster, right? Especially if you try to complete feats and maximize your score. Have you never had the stronger roster?
I think what I am realizing is that you are an extremist who:
1.) is not reading responses thoroughly.
2.) not actually taking the time to understand where the other side is coming from.
3.) cant let this go
I understand your perspective and we have all made our counter arguments and at the end of the day, we just see things differently. Take a couple of deep breaths and realize I am not your enemy, I am just a person who has a different perspective.
