I think it was unfair before. But with so many people soloing the raid the fact that it’s unfair is amplified. I mean their are guilds were more then 10 people solo it and people are randomly assigned Worse rewards. Many guild rotate who can get top 10, but that’s sucks too because players are required to get less rewards.
As for people that say if the whole guild gets the same good rewards that only a few will carry the group. I’d say those people need to find a new guild then. My guild keeps me active and engaged, honestly there are times I may have quit without then. If my guild mates upgrade their toon we all benefit from that, helps in TB and TW.