Mace Windu....

"Eriadano;c-1604909" wrote:
There are too many other good jedi to be used.

First time I've seen that phrase uttered, normally I've been told the opposite :lol:

"Wardai;c-1604958" wrote:
First time I've seen that phrase uttered, normally I've been told the opposite :lol:

All things are relative.

When Mace is the standard of comparison? The list of good Jedi is pretty much everyone but Kit Fisto.

I agree he should be an Attacker instead of Tank. Mace just doesn’t fit the role of a Tank and he wasn’t a very good one at that lol just ask Saesee Tiin, Agen Kolar, and Kit Fisto...

Mace’s combat form, Vaapad, is a very aggressive variant of Juyo. It’s not a defensive stance like Soresu or Shien/Djem So.

By the way, the only true Jedi tanks in the game are General Kenobi, Old Ben, and Kanan Jarrus. Plo Koon is just as bad as Mace and definitely needs a rework. Ima-Gun-Di is tagged as Support, but his description reads “Supportive Tank”. Jedi Knight Guardian just... sucks.

The problem is that the devs are mistakenly giving the tag “Tank” to characters that aren’t really designed as tanks, but “Survivor’s”. A “Tank” is a role that protects their allies first and foremost, and can withstand enemy attacks that would kill weaker allies. The way some of these “tanks” are designed is as a “Survivor” that doesn’t protect their allies, but is able to shrug off damage/debuffs. *Looking at you JKG and IGD*

Guardians (in the lore) were trained to attack and be capable of tanking....haha

They need reworked too but there’s zero chance of that! Ideally new artwork/animation. A strong attacking basic attack (but not too strong or amazing), a taunt and something else...