Forum Discussion
Whatelse73
6 years agoRising Adventurer
"Ultra;c-1691132" wrote:"NicWester;c-1691096" wrote:Did you read his post? Its implying that the OP might've missed other factors that's causing him to do less damage."CG_SBCrumb;c-1689275" wrote:
Hi folks,
As mentioned above, Offense Up and Offense Down should cancel each other out and provide NO net change to your damage if you have both. Does anyone have a screenshot or video that we can take a look at? It might help determining what's happening here.
I mean no offense, but it's a lot easier for you guys to test this than it is for us. We have to look for the right opponents and finagle hoping to find the right circumstances, then also be Johnny Quick Fingers on the screenshot--but then also have to do a bunch of other battles to find out what normal damage is without any buffs or debuffs.
Now, if you're saying that you've tested it and it looks fine to you and you want us to send screenshots when it isn't fine, that's totally understandable and great and we can. But we can't tell if it was run a couple times on your end from that post.
I've seen a lot of users not realize these sorts of things (other toons and their kits and the interaction between all the toons on the field). It could be a defense up buff, it could be a reinforcement ability or a passive unique of another ship causing the decreased damage.
For example, Geonosian Spy does +50% bonus damage against buff enemies. So when you attack Sun Fac (without a buff on Geo Spy) while he's not taunting and Sun Fac when he's taunting (he's buffed) it might do a different damage.
Geo spy grants +10% offense for each active geo ally. It could be that before having offense up/down there were 3 Geos and after having both status buffs, there are less geos on the field
We won't know what's really going on unless we can see a picture of the damage before and after the offense up/down debuff on the same toon by the same toon. He's trying to help out OP here for once, while implying that their testing showed no difference in damage dealt
1. I don't fight against Geo line-ups.
2. I mainly do mirror matches against other Thrawn leads with Tie Advanced, Biggs, and a TF or Tie Slicer out front.
3. Defense up isn't present when I'm doing this (I've tried against Tie Advanced, Biggs, Boba, etc.) It isn't crit immunity either.
4. I see my crits from Phantom with Offense up at 77K damage. With no offense up 52K-ish. With offense down 26-32K damage. With offense up AND offense down, 30-32K damage.
5. I don't have video to use because I don't have a phone that can do that. I don't feel like putting my game on my PC.
6. Maybe the game changers can take a look at it and give it a shot? Oh, wait.....
I appreciate the discussion here though! Thanks for providing input all.
About SWGOH General Discussion
Discuss and share your feedback on Star Wars: Galaxy of Heroes with fellow players.77,279 PostsLatest Activity: 14 hours ago
Related Posts
Recent Discussions
- 3 hours ago
- 4 hours ago
- 9 hours ago
- 14 hours ago