Forum Discussion

LLTSWrathe's avatar
LLTSWrathe
Seasoned Novice
4 years ago

Platoons

Platoons just really are a bad player experience. Everyone is trying to do their best, they want to 4/4 waves, but oops, you have to give away Rex, or C-3P0 or some other vital piece of a team that there's really no working around it. You were selected to suck.

It's one thing to force a character check to ensure proper roster depth for a guild. You can do that and still allow the unit to be fought w/, IMO. That would be a much better play experience.

Heck, you could even calculate the depth requirements automatically then and no longer require people to actively platoon characters at all. That would let guilds start working on CM's faster vs. sitting around and waiting for people to fill their spots.

The harsh measure to ensure proper preparation is the gear requirements to actually DO the mission, hehe. Just a thought.
  • Platoons are even worse for the person who goes out and buys the latest and greatest characters or ships and then has to donate that thing and never gets to try it out. ??‍♂️
  • "Sewpot;c-2297301" wrote:
    Platoons are even worse for the person who goes out and buys the latest and greatest characters or ships and then has to donate that thing and never gets to try it out. ??‍♂️


    Care to show any new thing that someone cant use right now?
  • "Kyno;c-2297315" wrote:
    "Sewpot;c-2297301" wrote:
    Platoons are even worse for the person who goes out and buys the latest and greatest characters or ships and then has to donate that thing and never gets to try it out. ??‍♂️


    Care to show any new thing that someone cant use right now?


    There's 12 Lord Vaders in the platoons right?
  • "TVF;c-2297326" wrote:
    "Kyno;c-2297315" wrote:
    "Sewpot;c-2297301" wrote:
    Platoons are even worse for the person who goes out and buys the latest and greatest characters or ships and then has to donate that thing and never gets to try it out. ??‍♂️


    Care to show any new thing that someone cant use right now?


    There's 12 Lord Vaders in the platoons right?


    Well that's not a problem; it's a Light Side TB.
  • Platoons are a bit of a bummer, especially if you are one of the people with lower geared toons. Echobase is odd too, it would pick my R5 3PO no zeta over a G12 z3PO.

    If the CM's weren't so silly, it wouldn't be a big deal. But assuming everyone is sitting on at least (3) Jedi Teams and (3) other LS teams that can go 4/4 is not realistic.

    Though you can ask for others in your guild that don't need a certain toon to place in your place.
  • Platoons are actually quite a good way of building cooperation in your guild - and the added bonus abilities they give your teams offsets the resource costs when it comes to getting stars. If you’re struggling with them, you might find something like EchoStation helps (if you have a guild discord) - it coordinates platoon assignments. Try not to think of them as an individual chore but as a collective effort and you should see some benefits
  • Platoons make our guild complete way more mission waves than we could without the buffs, debuffs they provide.
  • adamja's avatar
    adamja
    Rising Newcomer
    it is meant to make people cooperate and find out how to min max the best way, you might get less waves but overall more waves on guild level because platoon bonus. then it became bland and boring, i think it should be changed
  • LLTSWrathe's avatar
    LLTSWrathe
    Seasoned Novice
    "Crayons;c-2297311" wrote:
    Platoons make our guild complete way more mission waves than we could without the buffs, debuffs they provide.


    I'm not suggesting the buffs / debuffs going away, just that you're actually able to use the unit in combat still.

    I've not seen the issue of new characters being in Platoons for a long, long time. I don't know if that was a creative decision, or just that we've not had a new TB piece of content for it to include new characters yet. Hopefully time will tell on that soon (new TB content? Please?)
  • "crzydroid;c-2297335" wrote:
    "TVF;c-2297326" wrote:
    "Kyno;c-2297315" wrote:
    "Sewpot;c-2297301" wrote:
    Platoons are even worse for the person who goes out and buys the latest and greatest characters or ships and then has to donate that thing and never gets to try it out. ??‍♂️


    Care to show any new thing that someone cant use right now?


    There's 12 Lord Vaders in the platoons right?


    Well that's not a problem; it's a Light Side TB.


    No wonder my SLKR was so bad!