Forum Discussion

MajMoonunit's avatar
MajMoonunit
New Novice
2 hours ago

Proposal: A 3-Star Era Bracket with Scaled Rewards in Coliseum

Hi Capital Games team and fellow Holotable players,

First, I want to be completely clear: I have zero issues with players who spend money on this game. People earn their money, can spend it however they choose, and ultimately keep the servers running for all of us.

However, as a Free-to-Play (F2P) player on a fixed pension, spending simply isn't an option for me. Across both of my F2P accounts—sitting at 3.6 million GP and 6 million GP—the massive payout disparity in Coliseum has created an almost impossible wall for early-to-mid game players, whether they are trying to save up for Aurodium Lightspeed Tokens (LSTs) to catch up on older rosters (which is how I personally prefer to spend my currency) or trying to chip away at Relic 10 prerequisites for Galactic Legends.

The core issue in Coliseum isn't just overall account GP—it is Era Character Star Levels, which directly cap how high you can raise a unit's Era Level. Because F2P players unlock new Marquee units at 3 stars, we hit a hard level ceiling right away while competing on the exact same leaderboards as 4-star to 7-star rosters. Getting stuck in the lowest payout tiers—normally earning 150 Era Currency a day (with my highest ever payout being 300), while top ranks earn thousands—slows meaningful progression to a crawl.

For example, on my 6M GP account during the New Republic Era, all of my New Republic characters were locked at 3 stars throughout the active Coliseum window. Now that the Era has ended and they are farmable, I’ve worked them up to 6 stars and Relic 3–5 (with one at Gear 12, and Carson Teva and New Zeb nearly at 7 stars). Because of the one-year rule, these new units cannot be boosted with Lightspeed Tokens—F2P players have to farm them the long, traditional way. We are willing to put in the grind, but being capped at 3 stars against 7-star rosters during the active Era shuts us out of earning enough Era Currency to build up our older rosters with Aurodium LSTs or work toward Relic 10 materials.

To keep F2P and developing players engaged without hurting the game's economy or diminishing spender value, I’d like to propose a Star-Gated Bracket System for Coliseum:

How It Would Work:

• 3-Star Era Bracket: Create a dedicated Coliseum bracket specifically for players running 3-star Era characters (along with loaner units capped at the 3-star level limit).

• 4-Star & Up Bracket: Any player who promotes an Era unit to 4 stars or higher (whether through bundles or saved crystals) automatically graduates into the main competitive bracket for full reward access, ensuring matches are always grouped by actual unit power rather than payment method.

• Scaled-Down Rewards: To protect the game's economy and keep top-end payouts meaningful, the 3-Star bracket would feature scaled-down rewards (for example, 40% to 60% of the main bracket's Era Currency). It wouldn't match spender payouts, but it gives F2P players a steady, fair path toward Aurodium LSTs and Relic 10 materials.

Why This Works for Everyone:

1. Fair Competition: Players compete purely on strategy and Era Level execution within the 3-star cap rather than hitting a hard star-gate wall.

2. Zero "Smurfing" or Loopholes: Unlike GP caps, players cannot manipulate their roster to stay in the lower tier—the moment you promote an Era character to 4 stars, you move up.

3. Protects Spender Value: Players who invest in 4-star to 7-star Era characters still enjoy exclusive access to the highest reward tiers and fastest progression in the main bracket.

4. Keeps Guilds Healthy: Giving early-to-mid game F2P players a realistic path to Aurodium LSTs and R10 prerequisites—especially when new units must be farmed the slow way—keeps them motivated and active in their guilds.

Thanks for reading and considering a balanced solution that keeps Coliseum fun and rewarding for every type of player!

2 Replies

  • Thanks for taking the time to share your perspective. I understand your approach to saving crystals for marquee characters, particularly for Journey Guide requirements and future Lightspeed Tokens. That's a perfectly valid F2P strategy.

    However, I think there's an important distinction in the intended audience for my proposal.

    As I mentioned in the original post, I'm specifically trying to address the situation faced by early-to-mid game and developing accounts. There's a considerable difference between an account that unlocks new Marquee characters at three stars and simply cannot afford to promote them during an active Era, and a more established account with sufficient crystal reserves to take those characters to five or six stars.

    My proposed three-star bracket isn't intended to give resource-rich accounts an easier route to higher rewards. It's intended to give developing players, who are effectively locked at three stars from the outset, a more accessible way to accumulate Era Currency towards Aurodium LSTs and Relic 10 materials.

    I do agree with your point about RNG potentially becoming a problem in a three-star bracket. If everyone operates with similar star levels and Era progression, daily rankings could become heavily dependent on luck. One possible solution would be to flatten the reward curve within that bracket, reducing the disparity between the highest and lowest positions and providing more consistent daily rewards.

    I appreciate the constructive criticism, and I'm certainly open to refining the proposal.

    Ultimately, I'm looking for a solution that helps developing players remain engaged and make meaningful progress without taking anything away from those who have invested more heavily in their Era characters.

    Thanks again for contributing to the discussion.

  • there are quite a few problems with this, mostly the fact that dividing it into 3 stars and 4 stars+ will be a massive disadvantage for f2p players who get their marquee characters to 4/5 stars for the lightspeed tokens

    so for example in the current shard system there's all sorts of players, at the top there's the whales with 7 stars and really high Era Levels, and lower down there's players who invested less and less until we have the players who don't get shards but actively engage in coliseum and people who don't engage in coliseum at all

    so for instance in my f2p account I save crystals to get marquee characters to 5/6 stars (5 for the journey guide, 6 if I like the character/think it is powerful), and I rank around 120-50 in coliseum every day in the current shard, which again as previously mentioned has all sorts of players. with your proposed system, I would be in a shard with other f2p players who invest in these marquee characters and also whales, which now mean I'm at the bottom of the barrel and would get much less era currency than before

    the 3 star brackets also have problems being that (assuming no one spends on era leveling materials) it would literally be RNG for who gets the top spot every day since everyone's era levels will be pretty much the same, and if you haven't noticed RNG causes a lot of frustration for the players. this RNG is also a problem like even with the scaled down rewards (im taking the average 50%) the top spots would get substantially more era currency (1500) than the lower spots (75)

Featured Places

Node avatar for SWGOH General Discussion

SWGOH General Discussion

Discuss and share your feedback on STAR WARS™: Galaxy of Heroes with fellow players.Latest Activity: 13 minutes ago
85,318 Posts