If you have a guild with members who can basically solo a raid, what rules does your guild have? What is fair for the guild? (This is for Heroic Rancor)A. 24 hours zero damage, after that its ffaB. 24 hours zero damage, after that there's a damage cap (if so, what is the cap?).C. You put a damage cap only (if so, what is the cap?).D. Other?(The zero dmg rule is so that everyone has time to post a zero and get rewards)

24 hour 0 damage for my guild. And every single time at least 1 person does hundreds of thousands of damage. It’s usually a new member with a disabled chat.Then I boot them because they didn’t/don’t care/can’t read any of my posts that I place everywhere about this rule. Harsh yes but necessary.

I do 12 hour zero damage. then 12 hour 250k cap. then ffa

AAnd I might add: I've never been a fan of capping damage. Think about your strongest guild members, they'll have worked hard (or spent well) to build their teams, and won't appreciate that work being strangled via a cap.There is an argument for helping less strong members of the guild and raising the bar for them but my belief is that this is done by sharing sound advice on mods, team setup, strategy etc. - raising those players up rather than holding back your big hitters.

A is simple (easy to understand and implement) and works well. If your guild has a mix of few people with 7* Han, while the rest are still farming him, you could put a damage cap of 1 or 2 million for those, who already finished him, to let the rest of the guild take top—10 rewards with more shards. If that's not the case, I don't see a reason for using damage cap.

Yeah, I'm not liking the dmg cap either. I think its decidedly a bad idea.

Question about how to handle raid rules. Poll:

masseffectchris
8 years ago
24 hour 0 damage for my guild. And every single time at least 1 person does hundreds of thousands of damage. It’s usually a new member with a disabled chat.Then I boot them because they didn’t/don’t care/can’t read any of my posts that I place everywhere about this rule. Harsh yes but necessary.
herbvis
8 years ago
I do 12 hour zero damage. then 12 hour 250k cap. then ffa
AriellaSun
8 years ago
A

And I might add: I've never been a fan of capping damage. Think about your strongest guild members, they'll have worked hard (or spent well) to build their teams, and won't appreciate that work being strangled via a cap.
There is an argument for helping less strong members of the guild and raising the bar for them but my belief is that this is done by sharing sound advice on mods, team setup, strategy etc. - raising those players up rather than holding back your big hitters.
Waquira
8 years ago
A is simple (easy to understand and implement) and works well. If your guild has a mix of few people with 7* Han, while the rest are still farming him, you could put a damage cap of 1 or 2 million for those, who already finished him, to let the rest of the guild take top—10 rewards with more shards. If that's not the case, I don't see a reason for using damage cap.
KN9990
8 years ago
Yeah, I'm not liking the dmg cap either. I think its decidedly a bad idea.
naraiceylob
8 years ago
"Drew102379;c-1399675" wrote:
I’ve got a question my guild it either disbanded or kicked me out but I had Raid progress. On both raids And now its saying I can’t even play anymore.

If you are kicked you are out of the raid. If you join a new guild you have to wait for them to launch a new raid.
naraiceylob
8 years ago
"Drew102379;c-1400811" wrote:
"Naraic;c-1399818" wrote:
"Drew102379;c-1399675" wrote:
I’ve got a question my guild it either disbanded or kicked me out but I had Raid progress. On both raids And now its saying I can’t even play anymore.

If you are kicked you are out of the raid. If you join a new guild you have to wait for them to launch a new raid.

I just want to play and have some fun and it seems like every guild I join they boot me.

Do you ask what the guild rules are and do you follow them?
Actuwlly first when you join a guild do you see guild chat.
Panamaxed
8 years ago
Most guilds do 24 hour zero damage. when rancor opens for danage, those that solo do not post a a score untill the rest that dont solo, finish it amoung themselves.
jarhead733
8 years ago
A
allformysaviour
8 years ago
We have xx hr rule, damage cap, and 2 separate teams. Works well for us