Hi,
we have a more managed form of a rancor raid.
First 24h is a zero dmg policy (we tolerate up to 10k).
The second 24h (starting at 9pm / ending at 10pm) is moderated. Everybody can do as much dmg as they please, but with a twist.
Phase 1 can be closed the earliest at 9:15pm, Phase 2 at 9:30pm, Phase 3 at 9:45pm and finaly P4 closes officialy at 10pm - sometimes we tend to let it openended, but that happens very rarely.
Guildmembers who wanna solo the whole raid (pointwise) can do so, but can't log their score until 10pm. Everyone who tries but fails to solo and stucks in on of the phases have to wait until the timeframe allows him to log his score.
Its more handholding, but it works. P1 & P2 often closes earlier, but not because some member is greedy, it's because the mass amount of mini-dmg that sums up. That didn't change the timeframe for P3 or P4. We had 26 recorded rancor raids with these rules and only one that got finished before 10pm.
Of course sometimes someone is new or did the raid afk and logs the dmg to early. Those members get a warning. 2+1 Warnings earn you a kick, also we track all data on our website and have a mini-game there, where we award points for participating on raids, ranking 1-5 and deducted these scores with warning-penalties.
Nothing meaningfull, but its funny ... keeping High Score lists beside the game keeps them in check, everybody loves Highscores. :)
/salute
