I posted this on the Reddit thread as well, but forgetting about the rewards since we know these are being looked at on all raids, the major problem wirh this raid really is mechanics.
I think the raid is outstanding mechanicaly for heroic tier, but as you go down tiers and as the GP of the guild goes down with it, the target audience the raids are intended for do not have the rosters to deal with the mechanics since those dont scale down as well each tier also. Particularily Nihilus’ mechanics are severly punishing, the stacking tenacity hurts those with smaller rosters if the teams built by those lower GP players rely heavily on debuffs, etc.. that all works on the top end, but doesnt translate as the tiers go down.
From a heroic perspective, there are a few things that are concerning, the RNG can be extremely annoying, especially with Nihilus, the random 3rd hits can just destroy a good run. Down the road 4-5 months when it is just being farmed for gear and shards, that RNG is going to be even more frustrating. It is worth dealing worth now for the Traya shards, once that is not a factor though, it will be a constant point of irritation. The mode has to remain fun years from now, Im not sure if those annoyances give it that kind of sustain.
Capital Games Team
