So just wanted to know how everyone is feeling about the state of there guilds. I am seeing a large number of guilds looking not for just 1 or 2 members but groups of players. I know our Guild lost 3 members this last week as they decided they need time away from the game. Time ill tell how long they stay away. I know as an officer it is getting harder and harder to recruit at the level we need. We can get lower players but they would not be able to help us in Geo TB and would probably hurt us in TW. I mean we would love to bring in 5 or 6 good players but it is not happening. i mean maybe if some smaller guilds broke up moving groups of there players to 3 or 4 guilds it would help some of this but the idea of breaking up a guild is a non starter to most. So any thoughts? anything that can be done? does anyone even want anything done?

Lost 5 members all due to Relics and all 4.4 GP +, and more if light side Geo isn’t great or some great content doesn’t get announced soon... a lot of 200k+ Guilds are hurting

225M 29* Geo guild, lost two major players so far. Overall mood is a bit depressing right now.

It's more an issue of pride than an actual problem. There are plenty of guild with 43-47 members and new guilds are opening every day. I every 10th guild of similar capacity (there are hundreds even of 200m+ guilds) broke up (possibly within an alliance, if the problem is staying together with friends), the problem would be solved, but as long as everyone insists on keeping their guild there won't be a solution.Unless your guild has a strong enough status to attract a surplus of new candidates, of course.

We lost 8 players because of relics. People either quit or joined more relaxed guilds. Staying competitive became more expensive when relics dropped.

My previously 220GP Top 50 TW guild lost 3 right after the TB ended, and they all cited Relics.Another 2 officers have been discussing it pretty consistently enough that it's difficult to dismiss.The idea of new Relic only abilities furthering the distance between players and guilds has demoralized them...and we haven't been able to fill a single one of our shortages yet.We've never gone more than hours without replacing someone.

State of Guilds? | EA Forums

67 Replies

Jerrick_Kharr87
6 years ago
Why would anyone be quitting? Isn’t adding another tedious grind to an already tedious grind of a game fun and exciting??!!! Everyone cries for new content and they just added gear 14,15,16,17,18,19, and 20 but call them “relics”.....that’s new content right?? Right??!!!! ???‍♂️
Pulsipher
New Ace
6 years ago
We lost 4.... but I think they were losing interest after 3+ years anyway, the changes in game just acted as the catalyst. Participation in chat rooms - or lack of - told me they were heading in that direction months ago.
We had no problem filling back up with hungry and enthusiastic members at the 200M GP range. I think a guild or three packed it in and the refugees have bolstered the guilds that stayed focus. Those sorts of shifts are necessary and sometimes need a push to get going too.
Nikoms565
6 years ago
"Gifafi;c-1964740" wrote:
we're good.

It's like people forgot what hsth did to guilds

This. The top 10 heavy rewards are still a sticking point for many.
tvsfrink
6 years ago
"Nikoms565;c-1965597" wrote:
"Gifafi;c-1964740" wrote:
we're good.

It's like people forgot what hsth did to guilds

This. The top 10 heavy rewards are still a sticking point for many.

Pretty sure that wasn't the point.
nothingfac947
6 years ago
Newer players: "please add a slingshot mechanic so we can join our friends that have been around for a while. "
Day 1 players "It's a resource management game. Newplayers won't be playing against vets. They need to put in time and money."
Also, day 1 players: "we can't fill our guilds because people keep leaving and can't be replaced!"
If only there we a way to help vet guilds get new recruits to replace retirees.
Mephisto_style
6 years ago
It would be kind of cool if CG put in place an in-game forced consolidation. Your guild drops to 20 it gets gobbled up by a guild that rose to 30. Be kinda like that movie Mortal Engines
GifafiTho
6 years ago
"Mephisto_style;c-1966396" wrote:
It would be kind of cool if CG put in place an in-game forced consolidation. Your guild drops to 20 it gets gobbled up by a guild that rose to 30. Be kinda like that movie Mortal Engines

sounds as awful as that movie. no offense (to you, but def offense intended to that movie)

Forum Discussion

State of Guilds?

67 Replies

About SWGOH General Discussion

Recent Discussions

Character idea: Ewok Jedi

MEATHEAD…Content Ideas you’ve never heard

Haven't received purchases

Compensation

Needs new management