Territory War Feedback

Our guild > Average of 1.3 milion GP with a few 2 mil players.

Total~: 65 mil GP.for 49 players


Enemy Guild > Average of 1.9 million with a handfull of 1.2 mil players

Total¬: 78 mil GP for 44 players


Do you see where the problem lies?


The enemy guild has characters our guild simply can't have because our players are not at the same level. This is not fair at all and the matchmaker is broken.


There is a big difference in having 1 player that has many good caracters and golded that is at 2 mil and 3 players that have the same thing but lesser.

Quantity does not mean quality.



So fix this and put more strict rules for the matchmaker,it's unbearable to think that we try our best,everyone is trying their best to make strategies ,coordonate,waste their time staying up looking at the TW map only to be beaten by a far superior team that doesn't even coordonate,and i tell you,they didn't coordonate,they just attacked everything,we had Empire teams in T1,Phoenix teams in T2,Sith teams in T3 with zetas and everything,it was all for nothing. (we didn't know that only this morning somebody looked their guild onto the ingame search motor)


Our strategy works,we won all of our past TW with similar level guilds(as of SWGOH and Ingame).

But these guys weren't similar,they were just strooling around stomping everything.

By the time we had finished everything we had they have just only started.


Am I even allowed to report the guild...


The Guild Wars should be : The best coordonating guild should win,not the best pay2win op stomping guild should win....


Let me tell you something : An single enemy player has cleared 15 of our Phoenix Squadrons (around 65.000 GP with good mods and omegas,etc)

15 PER SINGLE PLAYER DO YOU REALISE HOW HIGH HIS GP MUST BE?
THIS IS NOT FAIR,AT ALL.

Same here. Everyone of my members have maybe 4 or 5 gear xii characters at best most only one or two with a average gp of 1.5m but we get matched with a guild who are able to field solid walls squads with 3 or 4 gear xii in every squad. They have to be averaging 2m. We can barely scratch them while they blow thru all our defenses.

We do the same though...and they still break through...

We had put Gear 12 CLS teams in T2 to stop them,it didn't.

i hate to say it, but on Active GP you re only about 5m GP apart, which puts you very close conpared to other matchups. Move along.

The TW system seems to be missing the most basic part of a usual matchmaking system. If a guild loses, match them against slightly weaker opponents next time. If they still lose, move them down a bit again until you get to a point where they win as much as they lose. Opposite for people who win a lot; keep making it harder until they're fighting equal opponents.

I would be amazed if I heard this system is actually used for TWs. So far for my guild we've lost far more than we've won, and the most recent TW was probably the worst loss we've had yet, despite following a string of much less absolute losses.

"swgohfan29;c-1469105" wrote:

So why am i not affected? Am i protected somehow? I ve actually crashed a lot more in HAAT then in TW (none, by the way).

You probably connected to a different set of servers based on your location/region. Asian/Pacific region is bad from guild reports.

"SpadeFreeman;c-1469170" wrote:
The TW system seems to be missing the most basic part of a usual matchmaking system. If a guild loses, match them against slightly weaker opponents next time. If they still lose, move them down a bit again until you get to a point where they win as much as they lose. Opposite for people who win a lot; keep making it harder until they're fighting equal opponents.

I would be amazed if I heard this system is actually used for TWs. So far for my guild we've lost far more than we've won, and the most recent TW was probably the worst loss we've had yet, despite following a string of much less absolute losses.

Wait so we re punishing people who use better tatics and coordination than their opponents?

"Gavstar;c-1469176" wrote:

"swgohfan29;c-1469105" wrote:

So why am i not affected? Am i protected somehow? I ve actually crashed a lot more in HAAT then in TW (none, by the way).

You probably connected to a different set of servers based on your location/region. Asian/Pacific region is bad from guild reports.

I am in the asia/pacific reigon, on a island called Singapore. So that explains nothing

"swgohfan29;c-1469178" wrote:

"SpadeFreeman;c-1469170" wrote:
The TW system seems to be missing the most basic part of a usual matchmaking system. If a guild loses, match them against slightly weaker opponents next time. If they still lose, move them down a bit again until you get to a point where they win as much as they lose. Opposite for people who win a lot; keep making it harder until they're fighting equal opponents.

I would be amazed if I heard this system is actually used for TWs. So far for my guild we've lost far more than we've won, and the most recent TW was probably the worst loss we've had yet, despite following a string of much less absolute losses.

Wait so we re punishing people who use better tatics and coordination than their opponents?

They do this in games all the time. It's not punishing, it's rewarding by giving them an appropriate challenge, in both directions.

"newbornFL;d-159763" wrote:
Our guild > Average of 1.3 milion GP with a few 2 mil players.

Total~: 65 mil GP.for 49 players


Enemy Guild > Average of 1.9 million with a handfull of 1.2 mil players

Total¬: 78 mil GP for 44 players


Do you see where the problem lies?


The enemy guild has characters our guild simply can't have because our players are not at the same level. This is not fair at all and the matchmaker is broken.


There is a big difference in having 1 player that has many good caracters and golded that is at 2 mil and 3 players that have the same thing but lesser.

Quantity does not mean quality.



So fix your **** and put more strict rules for the matchmaker,it's unbearable to think that we try our best,everyone is trying their best to make strategies ,coordonate,waste their time staying up looking at the TW map only to be beaten by a far superior team that doesn't even coordonate,and i tell you,they didn't coordonate,they just attacked everything,we had Empire teams in T1,Phoenix teams in T2,Sith teams in T3 with zetas and everything,it was all for nothing. (we didn't know that only this morning somebody looked their guild onto the ingame search motor,big **** difference)


Our strategy works,we won all of our past TW with similar level guilds(as of SWGOH and Ingame).

But these guys weren't similar,they were just strooling around stomping everything.

By the time we had finished everything we had they have just only started.


Am I even allowed to report the guild...


The Guild Wars should be : The best coordonating guild should win,not the best pay2win op stomping guild should win....


Let me tell you something : An single enemy player has cleared 15 of our Phoenix Squadrons (around 65.000 GP with good mods and omegas,etc)

15 PER SINGLE PLAYER DO YOU REALISE HOW HIGH HIS GP MUST BE?
THIS IS NOT FAIR,AT ALL.

Im confused. You suggest that your guild has a concentration of power in fewer more powerful members, state the enemy has their GP more evenly spread, and then complain that they have fewer but more powerful/quality toons.

Dont get me wrong, were fed up of being matched against guilds with GP concentration in a few members with ultra meta toons that we dont have a hope of beating.

But if your guild has a skew of higher GP players, then its your guild that has an advantage here.