I think the penalties should start at 5%. Other than phase 1, no other phase can be solo'd, so why put a huge stopper on the entire raid? I also hope that you un-neuter GLs so they can be used as intended now that we're going to be beaten down by the 2% penalty. Did you consider that 99.99% of the guilds won't have 50/50 participation in the CRanky raid? Building more teams to use is great, but when you exhaust teams in the first phases there won't be anything left for P4. Again we as officers/GLs still have to micro-manage the raid to make sure we can finish it with (1) only certain teams, (2) not having members over-extend their roster, (3) making sure all phases are covered, and (4) we have enough juice to complete it.
