Where is sim option?

"StarSon;c-1849775" wrote:

"Chucko_marek;c-1846762" wrote:
We don't sim the hpit because the rewards aren't decent enough. The Haat would be the same, when it does become simmable.

Well, you're wrong. You should be simming, because the rewards are way better.

Well you're partly wrong ;)

It depends on how many people join and if you value individual rewards or group rewards. Also depends on which part of the rewards you value most.

"StarSon;c-1849775" wrote:

"Chucko_marek;c-1846762" wrote:
We don't sim the hpit because the rewards aren't decent enough. The Haat would be the same, when it does become simmable.

Well, you're wrong. You should be simming, because the rewards are way better.

No I'm not. I usually place in the top when playing. I should get better rewards than the people who just join the raid. I put in the effort to build a team, and to play the game. Effort should always be rewarded more than existence.
Now if I rode the coattails of the guild and usually placed below 25ish, yes they would be better.

You were rewarded plenty, you had a long run of placing in the top. This content is old now, and it just sounds like you don't want to share with the rest of your guild. Or maybe you need a more committed guild that fits your competitive play style better.

"TVF;c-1850828" wrote:
You were rewarded plenty, you had a long run of placing in the top. This content is old now, and it just sounds like you don't want to share with the rest of your guild. Or maybe you need a more committed guild that fits your competitive play style better.

The rewards for simming should be better, especially if it is that out of date.

"Chucko_marek;c-1850806" wrote:

"StarSon;c-1849775" wrote:

"Chucko_marek;c-1846762" wrote:
We don't sim the hpit because the rewards aren't decent enough. The Haat would be the same, when it does become simmable.

Well, you're wrong. You should be simming, because the rewards are way better.

No I'm not. I usually place in the top when playing. I should get better rewards than the people who just join the raid. I put in the effort to build a team, and to play the game. Effort should always be rewarded more than existence.
Now if I rode the coattails of the guild and usually placed below 25ish, yes they would be better.

Yes, you are. Your guild as a whole is getting stronger, making you more competitive in other areas, like TB and TW, which results in more rewards overall, which makes you stronger than taking top 3 in Pit every time.

They can't give top rewards to 50 players. There has to be some compromise. You can sim and get average rewards for the whole guild, or you can still play manual and get top rewards (which in many guilds will be no different, or worse, than average, given how many people can solo it now).