Malevolence STILL useless?! Really?!?

"Woodroward;c-2056580" wrote:

"PouffyHalo93;c-2056558" wrote:

"Akenno;c-2056553" wrote:

"littleMAC77;c-2056552" wrote:

"ScummerAntilles;c-2056548" wrote:

"littleMAC77;c-2056542" wrote:
Maybe try reading the combat mission requirements first. In Phase 2 the Executrix and Chimera are required capital ships. They fixed the bug (according to the patch notes) for the subsequent phases.

Are you **** me... really.

This is your **** answer. They "fixed it" so that people into Separatist content can reenact that memorable battle of Star Destroyers at Geonosis?

They forgot or **** up again, in making the SEPARATIST content they released along with these CLONE WARS game modes useable in those game modes and you're gonna come here on my thread and smugpost to me in their defense??

Really? No. Make it so I can use my Separatist content that I invested in in the Separatist game mode.

You can swear at me all you want, but that doesn't change the fact that the Chimera and Executrix are requirements in the current phase's missions. If you are unable to use the Malevolence in Phase 3, then it will be a problem and you can curse out CG for lying about fixing the bug

https://forums.galaxy-of-heroes.starwars.ea.com/discussion/223088/content-update-01-22-2020#latest

It is still a bad choice that a non-era ship is a requirement... Just delete the requirement or change it with the Malevolence.

You're complaining about non-era ships required? What about the fact that you need Darth Traya for platoons, cause I don't remember the sith Triumvirate fighting in the battle of Geonosis either, and all the other countless out of era heroes needed in platoons

Platoons were actually designed to be a way to use up the non era requirements so that's not a very good argument.

"littleMAC77;c-2056564" wrote:

"Akenno;c-2056553" wrote:

"littleMAC77;c-2056552" wrote:

"ScummerAntilles;c-2056548" wrote:

"littleMAC77;c-2056542" wrote:
Maybe try reading the combat mission requirements first. In Phase 2 the Executrix and Chimera are required capital ships. They fixed the bug (according to the patch notes) for the subsequent phases.

Are you **** me... really.

This is your **** answer. They "fixed it" so that people into Separatist content can reenact that memorable battle of Star Destroyers at Geonosis?

They forgot or **** up again, in making the SEPARATIST content they released along with these CLONE WARS game modes useable in those game modes and you're gonna come here on my thread and smugpost to me in their defense??

Really? No. Make it so I can use my Separatist content that I invested in in the Separatist game mode.

You can swear at me all you want, but that doesn't change the fact that the Chimera and Executrix are requirements in the current phase's missions. If you are unable to use the Malevolence in Phase 3, then it will be a problem and you can curse out CG for lying about fixing the bug

https://forums.galaxy-of-heroes.starwars.ea.com/discussion/223088/content-update-01-22-2020#latest

It is still a bad choice that a non-era ship is a requirement... Just delete the requirement or change it with the Malevolence.

Someone else said it, but claiming they didn't fix a bug is different that suggesting a change to the combat mission requirements. I am all for removing either/both of the CM reqs, in fact I think it would be great if they loaned us all a Malevolence for the p2 battle with Vulture droid (and then did something similar in P1 of LS Geo).

I've always considered changing the description to be a copout bug fix.

"Woodroward;c-2056584" wrote:
a

"TVF;c-2056581" wrote:

"Woodroward;c-2056580" wrote:

"PouffyHalo93;c-2056558" wrote:

"Akenno;c-2056553" wrote:

"littleMAC77;c-2056552" wrote:

"ScummerAntilles;c-2056548" wrote:

"littleMAC77;c-2056542" wrote:
Maybe try reading the combat mission requirements first. In Phase 2 the Executrix and Chimera are required capital ships. They fixed the bug (according to the patch notes) for the subsequent phases.

Are you **** me... really.

This is your **** answer. They "fixed it" so that people into Separatist content can reenact that memorable battle of Star Destroyers at Geonosis?

They forgot or **** up again, in making the SEPARATIST content they released along with these CLONE WARS game modes useable in those game modes and you're gonna come here on my thread and smugpost to me in their defense??

Really? No. Make it so I can use my Separatist content that I invested in in the Separatist game mode.

You can swear at me all you want, but that doesn't change the fact that the Chimera and Executrix are requirements in the current phase's missions. If you are unable to use the Malevolence in Phase 3, then it will be a problem and you can curse out CG for lying about fixing the bug

https://forums.galaxy-of-heroes.starwars.ea.com/discussion/223088/content-update-01-22-2020#latest

It is still a bad choice that a non-era ship is a requirement... Just delete the requirement or change it with the Malevolence.

You're complaining about non-era ships required? What about the fact that you need Darth Traya for platoons, cause I don't remember the sith Triumvirate fighting in the battle of Geonosis either, and all the other countless out of era heroes needed in platoons

Platoons were actually designed to be a way to use up the non era requirements so that's not a very good argument.

Source please.

logic. To deny the post, produce counter logic.

They claimed it was intended to use your entire roster. They gave bonuses to era specific teams and said they would never be required in platoons.

"Woodroward;c-2056584" wrote:
a

"TVF;c-2056581" wrote:

"Woodroward;c-2056580" wrote:

"PouffyHalo93;c-2056558" wrote:

"Akenno;c-2056553" wrote:

"littleMAC77;c-2056552" wrote:

"ScummerAntilles;c-2056548" wrote:

"littleMAC77;c-2056542" wrote:
Maybe try reading the combat mission requirements first. In Phase 2 the Executrix and Chimera are required capital ships. They fixed the bug (according to the patch notes) for the subsequent phases.

Are you **** me... really.

This is your **** answer. They "fixed it" so that people into Separatist content can reenact that memorable battle of Star Destroyers at Geonosis?

They forgot or **** up again, in making the SEPARATIST content they released along with these CLONE WARS game modes useable in those game modes and you're gonna come here on my thread and smugpost to me in their defense??

Really? No. Make it so I can use my Separatist content that I invested in in the Separatist game mode.

You can swear at me all you want, but that doesn't change the fact that the Chimera and Executrix are requirements in the current phase's missions. If you are unable to use the Malevolence in Phase 3, then it will be a problem and you can curse out CG for lying about fixing the bug

https://forums.galaxy-of-heroes.starwars.ea.com/discussion/223088/content-update-01-22-2020#latest

It is still a bad choice that a non-era ship is a requirement... Just delete the requirement or change it with the Malevolence.

You're complaining about non-era ships required? What about the fact that you need Darth Traya for platoons, cause I don't remember the sith Triumvirate fighting in the battle of Geonosis either, and all the other countless out of era heroes needed in platoons

Platoons were actually designed to be a way to use up the non era requirements so that's not a very good argument.

Source please.

logic. To deny the post, produce counter logic.

They claimed it was intended to use your entire roster. They gave bonuses to era specific teams and said they would never be required in platoons when they were required in battle.

Ergo Platoons are for everything BUT the era specific teams

"TVF;c-2056586" wrote:

"Woodroward;c-2056584" wrote:
a

"TVF;c-2056581" wrote:

"Woodroward;c-2056580" wrote:

"PouffyHalo93;c-2056558" wrote:

"Akenno;c-2056553" wrote:

"littleMAC77;c-2056552" wrote:

"ScummerAntilles;c-2056548" wrote:

"littleMAC77;c-2056542" wrote:
Maybe try reading the combat mission requirements first. In Phase 2 the Executrix and Chimera are required capital ships. They fixed the bug (according to the patch notes) for the subsequent phases.

Are you **** me... really.

This is your **** answer. They "fixed it" so that people into Separatist content can reenact that memorable battle of Star Destroyers at Geonosis?

They forgot or **** up again, in making the SEPARATIST content they released along with these CLONE WARS game modes useable in those game modes and you're gonna come here on my thread and smugpost to me in their defense??

Really? No. Make it so I can use my Separatist content that I invested in in the Separatist game mode.

You can swear at me all you want, but that doesn't change the fact that the Chimera and Executrix are requirements in the current phase's missions. If you are unable to use the Malevolence in Phase 3, then it will be a problem and you can curse out CG for lying about fixing the bug

https://forums.galaxy-of-heroes.starwars.ea.com/discussion/223088/content-update-01-22-2020#latest

It is still a bad choice that a non-era ship is a requirement... Just delete the requirement or change it with the Malevolence.

You're complaining about non-era ships required? What about the fact that you need Darth Traya for platoons, cause I don't remember the sith Triumvirate fighting in the battle of Geonosis either, and all the other countless out of era heroes needed in platoons

Platoons were actually designed to be a way to use up the non era requirements so that's not a very good argument.

Source please.

logic. To deny the post, produce counter logic.

They claimed it was intended to use your entire roster. They gave bonuses to era specific teams and said they would never be required in platoons.

Ah ok no source then. Thank you.

"Woodroward;c-2056606" wrote:

"littleMAC77;c-2056603" wrote:

"Woodroward;c-2056602" wrote:

"littleMAC77;c-2056600" wrote:

"Woodroward;c-2056593" wrote:

"littleMAC77;c-2056587" wrote:

"Woodroward;c-2056584" wrote:
a

"TVF;c-2056581" wrote:

"Woodroward;c-2056580" wrote:

"PouffyHalo93;c-2056558" wrote:

"Akenno;c-2056553" wrote:

"littleMAC77;c-2056552" wrote:

"ScummerAntilles;c-2056548" wrote:

"littleMAC77;c-2056542" wrote:
Maybe try reading the combat mission requirements first. In Phase 2 the Executrix and Chimera are required capital ships. They fixed the bug (according to the patch notes) for the subsequent phases.

Are you **** me... really.

This is your **** answer. They "fixed it" so that people into Separatist content can reenact that memorable battle of Star Destroyers at Geonosis?

They forgot or **** up again, in making the SEPARATIST content they released along with these CLONE WARS game modes useable in those game modes and you're gonna come here on my thread and smugpost to me in their defense??

Really? No. Make it so I can use my Separatist content that I invested in in the Separatist game mode.

You can swear at me all you want, but that doesn't change the fact that the Chimera and Executrix are requirements in the current phase's missions. If you are unable to use the Malevolence in Phase 3, then it will be a problem and you can curse out CG for lying about fixing the bug

https://forums.galaxy-of-heroes.starwars.ea.com/discussion/223088/content-update-01-22-2020#latest

It is still a bad choice that a non-era ship is a requirement... Just delete the requirement or change it with the Malevolence.

You're complaining about non-era ships required? What about the fact that you need Darth Traya for platoons, cause I don't remember the sith Triumvirate fighting in the battle of Geonosis either, and all the other countless out of era heroes needed in platoons

Platoons were actually designed to be a way to use up the non era requirements so that's not a very good argument.

Source please.

logic. To deny the post, produce counter logic.

They claimed it was intended to use your entire roster. They gave bonuses to era specific teams and said they would never be required in platoons when they were required in battle.

Ergo Platoons are for everything BUT the era specific teams

Then why does DS Hoth require so many Empire units in Platoons? And LS Hoth so many Rebels? And DS Geo so many Sepratists? And LS Geo so many Galactic Republic?

Why did they change DS and LS hoth to have fixed requirements? Why did they change them to not require things the same day as battles? Because of what I just said. Supposed to use your whole roster not just a tiny fraction of it.

Geo doesn't apply to when platoons were created and why, that's way after the fact and they said they abandoned their own rules for these ones to simply make it hard.

Geo TB is obviously NOT intended to use your whole roster.

Still doesn't explain why Hoth DS requires a bunch of Empire in platoons on days with Empire as a requirement. Where is the logic on that one?

You're coming at this backwards. Are you saying they don't require non era characters?

How am I coming at it backwards? You said the purpose of platoons was to not require the TB era platoons in them, yet all of the TBs require the era characters. What exactly is your point? That platoons allow you to fill some of the slots with non-era characters??

That platoons were created as a way to require non era characters. Which was stated in response to someone saying it made no sense non era characters are required in Geo TB platoons.

I never said that platoons were supposed to be safe from era toons. Saying "Everything that is in a is also in b" is not the same as saying "everything that is in b is also in a". I said the former, you argued against the latter.

"Woodroward;c-2056618" wrote:

"littleMAC77;c-2056615" wrote:

"Woodroward;c-2056606" wrote:

"littleMAC77;c-2056603" wrote:

"Woodroward;c-2056602" wrote:

"littleMAC77;c-2056600" wrote:

"Woodroward;c-2056593" wrote:

"littleMAC77;c-2056587" wrote:

"Woodroward;c-2056584" wrote:
a

"TVF;c-2056581" wrote:

"Woodroward;c-2056580" wrote:

"PouffyHalo93;c-2056558" wrote:

"Akenno;c-2056553" wrote:

"littleMAC77;c-2056552" wrote:

"ScummerAntilles;c-2056548" wrote:

"littleMAC77;c-2056542" wrote:
Maybe try reading the combat mission requirements first. In Phase 2 the Executrix and Chimera are required capital ships. They fixed the bug (according to the patch notes) for the subsequent phases.

Are you **** me... really.

This is your **** answer. They "fixed it" so that people into Separatist content can reenact that memorable battle of Star Destroyers at Geonosis?

They forgot or **** up again, in making the SEPARATIST content they released along with these CLONE WARS game modes useable in those game modes and you're gonna come here on my thread and smugpost to me in their defense??

Really? No. Make it so I can use my Separatist content that I invested in in the Separatist game mode.

You can swear at me all you want, but that doesn't change the fact that the Chimera and Executrix are requirements in the current phase's missions. If you are unable to use the Malevolence in Phase 3, then it will be a problem and you can curse out CG for lying about fixing the bug

https://forums.galaxy-of-heroes.starwars.ea.com/discussion/223088/content-update-01-22-2020#latest

It is still a bad choice that a non-era ship is a requirement... Just delete the requirement or change it with the Malevolence.

You're complaining about non-era ships required? What about the fact that you need Darth Traya for platoons, cause I don't remember the sith Triumvirate fighting in the battle of Geonosis either, and all the other countless out of era heroes needed in platoons

Platoons were actually designed to be a way to use up the non era requirements so that's not a very good argument.

Source please.

logic. To deny the post, produce counter logic.

They claimed it was intended to use your entire roster. They gave bonuses to era specific teams and said they would never be required in platoons when they were required in battle.

Ergo Platoons are for everything BUT the era specific teams

Then why does DS Hoth require so many Empire units in Platoons? And LS Hoth so many Rebels? And DS Geo so many Sepratists? And LS Geo so many Galactic Republic?

Why did they change DS and LS hoth to have fixed requirements? Why did they change them to not require things the same day as battles? Because of what I just said. Supposed to use your whole roster not just a tiny fraction of it.

Geo doesn't apply to when platoons were created and why, that's way after the fact and they said they abandoned their own rules for these ones to simply make it hard.

Geo TB is obviously NOT intended to use your whole roster.

Still doesn't explain why Hoth DS requires a bunch of Empire in platoons on days with Empire as a requirement. Where is the logic on that one?

You're coming at this backwards. Are you saying they don't require non era characters?

How am I coming at it backwards? You said the purpose of platoons was to not require the TB era platoons in them, yet all of the TBs require the era characters. What exactly is your point? That platoons allow you to fill some of the slots with non-era characters??

That platoons were created as a way to require non era characters. Which was stated in response to someone saying it made no sense non era characters are required in Geo TB platoons.

I never said that platoons were supposed to be safe from era toons. Saying "Everything that is in a is also in b" is not the same as saying "everything that is in b is also in a". I said the former, you argued against the latter.

Actually, you did say that CG said they would be free from era toons when required in a battle. This is false, and no amount of "Logic" will change the fact that the hoth TBs require Empire/Rebels when they are a faction for a CM.

"Woodroward;c-2056584" wrote:

logic. To deny the post, produce counter logic.

They claimed it was intended to use your entire roster. They gave bonuses to era specific teams and said they would never be required in platoons when they were required in battle.

Ergo Platoons are for everything BUT the era specific teams

No, you will not remake my and their words in your image. I said what they said and what they said still doesn't mean what you say it means.

"Woodroward;c-2056619" wrote:

Even if they messed up on platoon requirements in Hoth so it doesn't match what you quoted me quoting them saying, it still doesn't even have anything to do with the other post so there is nothing contradictory there.