Rogue 1 versus Phoenix squad?

I'll give you that I'm probably underestimating phenoix but your definitely underestimatimg R1 also. To be fair in Arena I use R2( he's R1 in my book cuz he's in the movie lol) instead of Baze, but R1 is no joke. Maybe Phenoix could be decent in arena. But I don't think they could compete with CLS and other top squads like R1
Jyn's also not the only useful one I'm raid Chirrut is amazing and Cassian can be pretty good.

If you have Baze than rogue one. Otherwise Phoenix

agreed with above. If you can clear all the CM battles in LSTB with your phoenix squad focus on Rogue 1 team. They are super helpful in Territory Battles and Cassian is a super underrated toon IMO.

Mid tier yeah, sure. A maxed out Phoenix squad will destroy a maxed out R1 team though.

The thing about Rogue one is they don't need any zetas to be really good. @DedrickRogue how could a Phenoix be better then Rogue One I'm confused? Maybe they are just as good in TB but In a PvP Rogue would easily take the cake. And R1 units are also much more useful in Raids.

A competitive r1 squad needs at least 1 zeta, on Jyn. The only thing that masks mediocre r1 squads is how crazy good Chaze is/was.

TB is a wash, both can clear p6 and both are required squads for LSTB.

Only Jyn is more useful in raids, the rest sit the bench.

Arena has to go to Phoenix. A full zeta(or even just 2 or 3) Phoenix is not the pushover you think. They get crazy TM gain, it's impossible to keep buffs off them, protection regen is WAY better the HoTs, they all counter, and have multiple buff wipers & taunters.

I think Phoenix needs their whole zetas to fully work and be hard to beat. In TW, I usually use Rogue One to beat them (without Chaze) using Jyn (no zeta), Cassian, K2, Bodhi and Bistan. Even if they're undergeared compared to the Phoenix, the amount of expose first heal them but nevertheless, when they have no protection anymore, 5 exposes are deadly.

"Creepioo;c-1399672" wrote:
I'll give you that I'm probably underestimating phenoix but your definitely underestimatimg R1 also. To be fair in Arena I use R2( he's R1 in my book cuz he's in the movie lol) instead of Baze, but R1 is no joke. Maybe Phenoix could be decent in arena. But I don't think they could compete with CLS and other top squads like R1
Jyn's also not the only useful one I'm raid Chirrut is amazing and Cassian can be pretty good.

R2 isn't a Rogue One character, regardless of whether he was in the movie.

Rogue One squads aren't a "top squads" in arena, and certainly not on the same level as CLS squads.

What raid is Chirrut or Cass amazing in?

Phoenix is an objectively better squad. They get you Thrawn, you need both ships for Chimaera, and multiple have triple tags. They are easily the best possible "return on investment" you can get out of 6 characters....they just are a pain to gear.

I agree getting Thrawn is a major bonus.
As far as Chirrut he's one of the best healers, he cleanses, and hits hard, he's really fast and gives buffs to survive p4 of the Tank if needed, and fits into many squads, he's amazing imo. Cassian has Speed down which can be really important in raids and has synergy with rebels so not amazing but good Imo.

And just because nobody uses R1 in your arena shard doesn't mean nobody does. I'm the only one in my Shard, and I can beat the CLS squads except about 10 that have mods way faster then mine. CLS is better at defense but I can still compete on offense.

"Creepioo;c-1399779" wrote:
And just because nobody uses R1 in your arena shard doesn't mean nobody does. I'm the only one in my Shard, and I can beat the CLS squads except about 10 that have mods way faster then mine. CLS is better at defense but I can still compete on offense.

Absolutely agree. I'm not even suggesting my specific launch shard is an perfect model of everyone's shards. I also am not suggesting a R1 team can't climb high in the ranks, even on an older shard. They are a very respectable team and a ton of fun to play. Chaze-less R1 is/was my last big full team project(Phoenix was before that, Troopers are next).

Most teams given the gear, synergy, mods and a zeta or two can take out 90% of the competition on offense. There will be that one or two leads or characters that are basically a hard counter, but most will climb just fine to a certain point. It's where you start running into issues, and how far you fall on D that is equally important. Phoenix and R1 both are fairly solid on D, but I give the edge to Phoenix. Zeta Kanan & Sabine are absolute monsters who can't be allowed to even take a single turn unless Ability Blocked.

Plus as stated they are required/help towards multiple more events, that alone in my eyes makes them the better squad to advise people to gear up.