Hello, I had a quick look for you at The Sims Resource. You are right that there is mostly eye makeup, but I found the Blossom Blush by Cleotopia that I thought was quite pretty.
The creator Xandher from the same website makes pretty lipstick.
The Sims Resource site is okay to download from, just make sure to click on the small purple download button because sometimes there are ads with a big green “Start Download” button, but that is an ad. I'm not sure why The Sims Resource would choose ads like that, because that’s confusing to people.
Although I use an awful lot of CC for the Sims 4, I don’t have any CC for the Sims 2 that is for CAS. But that Blossom Blush is so pretty that I will probably download it, and give it a try.
Are you looking for CC that is more the realistic type? I also thought Xandher made very pretty hair.
I wish you good luck with your search.