Hey there, @ChelleJo!
This fresh game folder that refuses to even startup to the Main Menu, does it have NRaas mods in it? Just a reminder, there are a couple of not good combos that will crash the game on startup every time.
1 - The MC Progression add-on module without BOTH MasterController and StoryProgression base mods.
2 - A mod that controls EA store content (e.g., Cupcake) when the store content (bakery set) is not present or refusing to load.
Just stabs in the dark really, but is either possible?
Edit: I would also be concerned about your graphics card being installed/listed in the dxdiag three times. I doubt you have three of the same graphics cards. It may need to be uninstalled and reinstalled, unless you know of a reason why it's showing up that way.