Lipstick bug... base game lipstick missing.

I could have sworn there were three different lipstick types for each color group (both the "normal colors" which are the reds, pinks,etc then the greens, blue, blacks/greys). The three lipstick types being a shiny lipstick, a more matte lipstick, and then the very sheer lipstick (gloss.) I have three lipstick choices for each of the two color groups, but two of my lipstick choices are the same exact consistency of lipstick, I think the more matte one. I still have the gloss, but it's like the shiny lipstick has gone missing and has somehow been replaced by the matte lipstick.

I have tried repairing my game, changing in game graphics settings, resetting game manually, and updating my graphics drivers. I do not nor have ever had CC or mods. 

I show all the base game lipsticks together as the same color in my first pic, note the two sets of lipstick that are the EXACT SAME.