Don Lothario vs. J Huntington III

I have to pick Don for nostalgia reasons XD I remember using him several times in sims 2

I swear, these two have some of the strongest genes in the game. Most definitely Don's chin, my legacy sims' two sons ended up resembling Bruce Wayne for a while there. :3

Still, I tend to use Don as a fling for my sims because I can't really take him seriously and he didn't care for children that much so he was kind of a dirt bag, especially if I'm playing the Goths (that brings back a load of memories, lol.), this is a dude who will go after both Caliente sisters and the mom if willing. Yeah, no thanks. J(avier) turned out to be a great father and friend in my playthrough. He's adorable as an Elder, though. Of course makeover wise? Can't deny they're both pretty hot.

Neither, I agree on Caleb part haha.

They are both completely unattractive imo...

Don is okay, but I love J way more. Not only is he cute (in a pixelated way) but he's a great partner for my Sims (if you get rid of the noncommittal trait of course) and an awesome dad. Speaking of being a dad, he even has strong genes for his kids, and I love that.