You have to have luck enabled under pack settings in order to craft it.
Thanks for clarifying, rosemow . Yes, there are plenty of all items needed. I just checked again and she had 84 lemons, 41 bones and 4 scared potions. I also tried dragging all og the three types of items to her personal inventory and to the table's inventory. Neither of those ways worked either. The Lucky Liquid remains greyed out. I would love, love, love to hear someone confirm that they can make the Lucky Liquid in their game. Seriously, that would help me out a lot to know.
I tested it and my sim couldn’t make it also. It was shown greyed out like the picture that you posted.She is level 10 apothecary skill also and had all the ingredients.
