Forum Discussion

Aidenguy00's avatar
5 years ago

Which gaming laptop brand is better?

hi. any opinions on which brand is better for gaming laptops? Asus or Lenovo.

I have been looking for months for a laptop cause mine is slow now and my price range is low so I am looking at asus tuf or lenovo.

i have seen bad reviews about asus laptops and how they have (don’t quote me on this) “a lot of quality control issues or don't last very long in an optimal state, and have low thermal throttle points on many of their lower-end units (as low as 75c)”. 

i just want to know people’s opinion on which brand is better and more reliable cause i want a long-lasting laptop and both of the laptops i am looking at are similar in specs and i just want to know which brand is better in general for gaming laptops.

9 Replies

  • @Aidenguy00  If you can afford a Lenovo Legion, its configurations are generally better than the Asus Tuf line, which can still be quite good.  Lenovo Ideapads are generally not.  Some of the higher-end Asus models are also high quality, for example the Zephyrus G14.

    When reading reviews, always be sure to double-check the dates and the models listed, because overall quality can change both over the long-term and sometimes from one year to the next.

  • Aidenguy00's avatar
    Aidenguy00
    5 years ago

    @puzzlezaddicthey, thank you for this advice.

    I decided I was going to get the Lenovo Gaming 3 laptop.

    I still want the Lenovo Ideapad Gaming 3 but I showed my mum and she’s buying it since she wants me to save my money for my future and she said she doesn’t like the plastic build of the Lenovo gaming laptop 3 and not keen on the colour as it can show fingerprints easily.

    So do you have any suggestions for a non-gaming laptop that will allow me to play The Sims 4 in Ultra settings please with no lag? I’ve got all the expansion packs and quite a lot of cc/mods.


    I don’t mind if the battery is a bit on the low side since I won’t be taking it anywhere. My budget is £750, only willing to go to £800 if it’s worth it. But would rather £750 and under. And I can only buy from Currys.co.uk.

    I’ve found these 3 non-gaming laptops below.

    Are they any good for ultra settings? But I do preferably want a bigger laptop with numerical keypad so please let me know if you have any suggestions.

    And I also want to be able to browse the internet on Chrome, use Microsoft Office etc. And Sims 4 is the only game I play.

    https://www.currys.co.uk/gbuk/computing/laptops/laptops/acer-swift-3-14-laptop-amd-ryzen-5-1-tb-ssd-purple-10208153-pdt.html

    https://www.currys.co.uk/gbuk/computing/laptops/laptops/lenovo-yoga-slim-7-14-laptop-intel-core-i5-256-gb-ssd-orchid-10208007-pdt.html

    https://www.currys.co.uk/gbuk/computing/laptops/laptops/lenovo-yoga-slim-7-14-laptop-amd-ryzen-5-256-gb-ssd-orchid-10209079-pdt.html

  • puzzlezaddict's avatar
    puzzlezaddict
    Hero+
    5 years ago

    @Aidenguy00  Among the three laptops you listed, performance should be about the same between the first and third.  I'd definitely cross off the second one though: its graphics chip is only about half as fast, which is a very large gap in gaming.  Still, you could do better.

    To play Sims 4 on ultra graphics settings, you really do need a laptop with a dedicated graphics card.  Even the low-end MX cards often can't handle ultra settings, although that depends to some degree on playstyle and what a person considers good enough performance.  For the next faster cards, that means a gaming laptop, at least until you get into the £1,200+ price range.

    You could get a non-gaming laptop with an MX card though.  The fastest one Currys has in stock, at least in your price range, is the MX350, which should be able to handle high settings; beyond that, you could play with the various options to see which combination works best for you.  This Acer has both an MX350 and a number pad:

    https://www.currys.co.uk/gbuk/computing/laptops/laptops/acer-aspire-5-a515-56g-15-6-laptop-intel-core-i5-512-gb-ssd-silver-10212833-pdt.html

    These two are £800; the Zenbook has some weird feature where the number pad appears on the touchpad, if you're into that kind of thing.  I don't think either of these are better than the one above; this is only if you happen not to like the first option for some reason.

    https://www.currys.co.uk/gbuk/computing/laptops/laptops/acer-aspire-5-a515-56g-15-6-laptop-intel-core-i7-512-gb-ssd-silver-10216776-pdt.html

    https://www.currys.co.uk/gbuk/computing/laptops/laptops/asus-zenbook-14-um433iq-a5037t-14-laptop-amd-ryzen-5-256-gb-ssd-grey-10208034-pdt.html

    The only other laptop with an MX350 I saw was this HP, but it doesn't have a number pad:

    https://www.currys.co.uk/gbuk/computing/laptops/laptops/hp-envy-13-3-laptop-intel-core-i5-512-gb-ssd-gold-10212904-pdt.html

    The MX250 is a little slower, but still significantly faster than an integrated graphics chip.  The only good options I saw didn't have a number pad though.

    https://www.currys.co.uk/gbuk/computing/laptops/laptops/acer-aspire-5-a515-54g-15-6-laptop-intel-core-i5-256-gb-ssd-silver-10198847-pdt.html

    https://www.currys.co.uk/gbuk/computing/laptops/laptops/dell-inspiron-13-5391-13-3-laptop-intel-core-i7-256-gb-ssd-silver-10218737-pdt.html

  • Aidenguy00's avatar
    Aidenguy00
    5 years ago

    Hi @puzzlezaddict, thank you for the detailed explanation for which non-gaming laptop would be best for me to play on the highest setting possible.

    I am interested in two of the laptops you mentioned:


    https://www.currys.co.uk/gbuk/computing/laptops/laptops/acer-aspire-5-a515-56g-15-6-laptop-intel-core-i5-512-gb-ssd-silver-10212833-pdt.html

    https://www.currys.co.uk/gbuk/computing/laptops/laptops/hp-envy-13-3-laptop-intel-core-i5-512-gb-ssd-gold-10212904-pdt.html

    As you have stated, they both have MX350 graphic cards so it is significantly slower compared to GTX 1650 which the Lenovo Gaming Ideapad 3 has.


    After doing research about these two, I also came across another non-gaming laptop with a separate graphics card and that laptop has GTX 1050. As below:

    https://www.currys.co.uk/gbuk/computing/laptops/laptops/acer-aspire-7-a715-74g-15-6-intel-core-i5-laptop-512-gb-ssd-black-10194242-pdt.html#wrapper

    Would this mean, this Acer Aspire 7 with GTX 1050 would allow me to play Sims 4 with Ultra settings unlike the MX350 laptops which would probably allow High settings? 

    And is this laptop better than the Acer Aspire 5 and HP Envy? 

  • puzzlezaddict's avatar
    puzzlezaddict
    Hero+
    5 years ago

    @Aidenguy00  The laptop with the 1050 is a gaming laptop, but that's not a bad thing, from my perspective at least.  It should outperform the other laptops by a significant margin.  I didn't mention it because I thought you weren't interested in gaming laptops, but it's certainly a good computer.

    The MX350 is actually a sized-down version of the 1050.  You get a smaller, lighter, less power-hungry graphics card; the tradeoff is you lose about 30% in performance.  So from a gaming standpoint, a laptop with a 1050 is clearly the better option.

    Right now, a 1050 can run all current Sims 4 packs on ultra settings, but maybe only barely, again depending on playstyle and other factors.  Depending on how you play, you may always be able to use ultra settings, but there's no guarantee.

  • Aidenguy00's avatar
    Aidenguy00
    5 years ago
    @puzzlezaddict Ohh I see! On Currys, it's not in the gaming laptop section and it is with the normal laptop section so I didn't know it was a gaming laptop. It certainly doesn't look like one haha.

    Yes, my mother doesn't like the Lenovo Ideapad gaming 3 since it is plastic and shows fingerprints but I think the Acer looks like a metal-painted body but still shows fingerprints as do most black laptops probably.

    Now I will have to decide whether to choose between the Ideapad Gaming 3 or Acer Aspire 7. I am more leaning towards the Ideapad just because of the GPU as it's guaranteed that Sims 4 can run on ultra settings, whereas, Acer Aspire 7 isn't necessarily guaranteed but then again the build quality of the Acer seems better.

    It's so difficult! Could you please weigh out the positive and negatives for the two laptops?
  • puzzlezaddict's avatar
    puzzlezaddict
    Hero+
    5 years ago

    @Aidenguy00  If we're talking about the Lenovo with the 1650, then that's a major positive for the Lenovo.  The 1650 is about 40% faster in gaming than the 1050, so even if the Lenovo doesn't run games to its full theoretical potential, it's still going to perform a lot better than any laptop with a 1050.

    I think the Lenovo has only 256 GB of storage, which is not a lot, even though it's more than enough for Sims 4.  If you have plans to store a significant amount of data on the laptop, you might be better off with the Acer's 512 GB storage.  You could of course buy an external hard drive, but that's not as convenient.

    The processor and RAM are equal, and the laptops' cooling benchmarks are similar, so there's not much to comment on there.

    Really though, this comes down to which laptop you like better.  While it's great to have the best in-game performance your budget can buy, you're using the laptop for other purposes too, and that matters.  I say this as someone with a MacBook Pro that I love: its gaming performance is nowhere near what I could have gotten for a comparably priced Windows system, but I'm on the Mac for hours every day and wouldn't trade it for a gaming laptop.  I can still play fine, on a graphics card that's a little slower than the 1050.  And yes, I do notice the difference, but on the other hand, I'm much happier when I'm doing everything else.

  • Aidenguy00's avatar
    Aidenguy00
    5 years ago

    @puzzlezaddictThose are very good points you make.

    Are the processors drastically different? I know the Acer Aspire is 9th gen and Lenovo is 10th gen and they are both Intel.

    Also is Aspire 7 RAM upgradable? I feel like it could be a good idea to make it more faster on google chrome etc if there is an extra slot to add another 8GB of RAM.

    That is very true in regards to using the laptop for other purposes too. To be fair, I use the laptop more to go on video calls, browse on Google Chrome, watch Netflix and use Microsoft Word & PowerPoint. I play The Sims 4 whenever I feel like it (so less) but I do like ultra settings hehe.

    So in that case, maybe the Aspire 7 is better as I guess the Lenovo is more of a gaming laptop so it focuses more on the gaming experience despite both of them being gaming laptops. Also, speaking of which, do you know if the Aspire 7’s screen is dull like Leveno’s apparently is and do they have the same webcam quality?

    I have seen reviews of RGB screen tests but I have no idea how to read them or interpret them, there’s so many things to consider, it’s crazy.

  • puzzlezaddict's avatar
    puzzlezaddict
    Hero+
    5 years ago

    @Aidenguy00  The improvement from the 9300H to the 10300H is quite small, a bit disappointingly so even, so it's not worth taking into account.  The Acer Aspire 7 has two slots for RAM and looks like it supports at least 32 GB, although you'd likely never use even 16.

    The maximum brightness of a screen is rated in nits, with 250 being a bit dim and 300 much better.  Matte vs. glossy is mostly about subjective taste.  IPS is the highest quality type of screen, with VA also good; TN panels are low quality.  The Aspire has a matte screeen and an IPS panel but not a particularly bright screen.  If you'd like some technical data, these two reviews provide a lot:

    https://www.notebookcheck.net/Aspire-7-A715-Laptop-Review-Acer-s-upgrade-giant-with-gaming-potential-and-long-battery-life.435242.0.html

    https://laptopmedia.com/us/review/acer-aspire-7-a715-74g-review-a-great-item-both-for-gaming-and-for-the-office/

    It might be simpler to just read the overviews of the screen though.  I should point out that neither of these reviews covers precisely the same model as is sold on Currys, but the screen is the same model.

    In this category of laptops, there really are no perfect screens.  That doesn't mean you shouldn't care, but it's something to keep in mind.