I have it and it's one of my favorite locations. It's a breathtakingly beautiful world. I was expecting a bit more of the Island Paradise gameplay, though. Surfing, windsailing, deep sea diving would have been nice. The mermaids are beautiful but a bit meh in gameplay, but I wasn't all that impressed with S3 mermaids, either. I'm glad they kept it more respectful of the indigenous culture instead of going for resorts and developed high rise condos. I've often played characters that moved away from society to live on an island, and this fits that gameplay like a glove. I don't usually play careers, so I can't comment on the conservationist gameplay. I approve of the concept, though, since I support several ocean conservation groups.