Game Packs ranking

1.Parenthood
2. Spa Day
3. Dine Out
4. Realm of Magic
5. My Wedding Stories
6. Outdoor Retreat
7. Jungle Adventure
8. Dream Home Decorator
9. Strangerville
10. Journey To Batuu
11. Vampires
12. Werewolves

Just like the EP I put them into categories. Ranking within a category is such a close call, it may vary depending on my mood

Must haves
1. Realm of Magic
2. Werewolves
3. Jungle adventures
4. Spa Day (merely for yoga and soak baths)
Useful/fun to play
5. Strangerville
6. Dine out
7. Parenthood
8. Journey to Batuu
9. Outdoor retreat
10. Vampires
Nice items but too little and buggy gameplay
11. Dream Home Decorator
12. My wedding stories

1. Dine Out - great for building community lots with activities. Restaurants can have so many different themes.
2. Strangerville - coolest pack around!
3. My Wedding Stories - love the world.
4. Jungle Adventure
5. Vampires
6. Werewolves
7. Outdoor Retreat
8. Spa Day
9. Realm of Magic
10. Parenthood - I hate the advice pop ups...
-
don't own:
Dream Home Decorator
Journey to Batuu

Starting with #1:

Jungle Adventure
Outdoor Retreat
Realm of Magic
Strangerville
Dine Out
Spa Day
Vampires
Dream Home Decorator - new, haven't fully explored yet
Parenthood

I don't own Werewolves, Wedding Stories or Batuu so no ranking for these yet.

1. Dine Out -> Restaurants are by far my most used lot type in the game. They are so versatile. You can have a classic Restaurant with so many different cultures and themes, but also I almost always make those big beautiful generic lots from the gallery into a Restaurant. So my Sims can visit any place, explore and at the end of the day they can eat there.
When a new World comes the first thing I do is add 1-3 different Restaurants.

2. Spa Day Like Restaurants, I add at least one Spa lot in every new world that fits the theme and vibe of the world. The animations are so realistic. Overall there are SO MANY new animations in this gamepack: Different massages, many yoga positions and fails, steam room animations. And thats what I love about it!
Oh, and the floor and wall tiles are my no. 1 tiles for every bathroom and kitchen I create!

3. Outdoor Retreat -> love the world for vacation, and those wood benches, the fireplace and the wooden outdoorlamps I use in almost every park.

4. Jungle Adventure -> The jungle world and the sounds of nature are absolutely stunning!!! I really enjoyed the adventures through the jungle and exploring the temples!! The new dance is lovely, the music is great and the furniture is high quality and rustic. Love this pack!

5. Parenthood -> great for my family Gameplay

6. Werewolves -> LOVE the B/B!!! I'm not a supernatural player, but the wolves are so cute, that I just had to turn my favourite Sim for a short period of time into a wolfie. This Pack (and a specific gallery build) inspired me to tell a very exciting and unusual story!

7. My Wedding Stories -> LOVE the world and the new dance!! It's so elegant and dreamy. And the new romantic song is one of my favourites in the Sims radio. And I might be the only person in the world who enjoyes the micromanaging part of the wedding. XD I pretty much micromanage everything else in my game so this was right up my alley. But the bugs make it difficult, so I'm happy for mod fixes.

8. Dream Home Decorator -> I'm not interested in the gameplay, but I adore the B/B, although I'm not too happy about the color palette. I REALLY miss my dark brown wood swatch that I mostly use. So thats a big minus.

9. Strangerville -> Usually I don't like playing storys that the game tells me, but this one was very cool and dramatic. I got very invested in the plot. The motherplant and the music freaked me out and I was SOOO excited along with my Sims. XD And the B/B is awesome in this pack.

10. Realm of Magic -> Not interested in the gameplay and B/B, but I like the cute little neighborhood in the woods.

11. Vampires -> Not interested in the gameplay, got it for the B/B mostly for the wall scratches ect.

12. Journey to Batuu -> I still haven't played the story, but want to do it at the right time. :) I like the world and the B/B. Very disappointing that we can't build there or stay for a while on a lot.

Overall I'm very happy with the Gamepacks we got so far.

I like to play flexibly so a numeric ranking is more of an approximation than a strict ranking but ok, sure, I play with different themes and with few regrets.

Favorites:
1. Parenthood with Growing Together - This does make families a lot more interesting and replayable. Families form the basis of a lot of my playstyle with a rotational legacy but then I change things up with fun activities.
2. Dine Out and Spa Day - I use both of these a lot for regular gameplay all the time. I've read a review that some players don't need a playable spa but this pack added a lot to my game. My sims like to bliss out and I like the detail in the yoga. I even appreciated the refresh with painting nails. I have numerous restaurants and several spas, I could see adding more. Dine Out has occasionally required bug fixes but I have it working now with Get Famous.
3. Jungle Adventure - I love the travel packs and this one is really fun. I ranked some packs I use more often slightly above it but I'm glad to have it. I've been to the region that it's about and it feels authentic. Very fun.
4. Strangerville - This was a hit for me and I have continued using the world a lot because I love the atmosphere. I like that they let you decide what to do with the world afterwards. I kept it as "normal" but it is a quirky small town that I play with.
5. Dream Home Decorator - I do like this pack, I use the CAS/BB a lot and I have a few competing decorators in my game. I've made some quirky interior design with this pack. I had never seen so much cosmolux before, lol, but now one of my houses is a swinging 60's mansion. Fun to play.
6. My Wedding Stories - Tartosa is a setting I really wanted in my game. I've just lightly used this pack so far but I've been getting the hang of it and I do understand it. I will keep using it and Tartosa is definitely a place I'll enjoy with Sims.
7. Vampires - I only have a few vampires but this is a great pack. I appreciate the Victorian decor that I use elsewhere. I do have the vampires in my game but I restrict them to just a few. They are very detailed and it's a great pack for occult play.
8. Outdoor Retreat - I do actually use this camping site especially for family-friendly trips or for sims who just want time outdoors in the woods. I've played with most of the features in it and I enjoy it. It would be great if they would add swimming in this world.
9. Realm of Magic - I'm not an occult player.
10. Journey to Batuu - It's not entirely my style of play but I have played with it and probably will again at some point. I'm glad that it exists for people who really want that playstyle.
11. Werewolves - I have not played with this one and it is not really my style. The world does interest me but the theme and the CAS/BB aren't really my thing. I do appreciate that we have the option to restrict werewolf play to just Moonwood Mill. It's possible that I'll play this a bit at some point.

I realize that my list is not everyone else's list. Honestly, I enjoy just about all of what I have. I don't mind that they make occult content at all, I'm just a very occasional player with that stuff whereas I play a lot with a more realistic but not boring style. A lot of the list is almost tied for me.

1. Parenthood
2. Strangerville
3. Jungle Adventure
4. Dine Out
5. Spa Day
6. Werewolves
7. Realm of Magic
8. Vampires
9. Dream Home Decorator
10. Wedding Stories (Just the world itself is worth it)
11. Outdoor Retreat
12. Batuu

Must Haves:
1. Vampires - Love this occult and play with them all the time.
2. Spa Day - The wellness skill is one of my favorites and almost all of my sims end up doing it.
3. Jungle Adventure - I never get tired of exploring this world and the archeology skill is also one of my favorites.
4. Realm of Magic - While not perfect, I also love this occult and use them all the time.

Like to Have:
5. StrangerVille - I don't play with it often, but I love the story and the world.
6. Outdoor Retreat - Mostly for the camping gear, but I also love the world.
7. Parenthood - This one has fallen a bit in my rankings, but I still like it.
8. Dine Out - I mostly just like building restaurants, but it's fun to play with them once in awhile.
9. Werewolves - Well done, but just not my cup of tea.
10. Dream Home Decorator - I mostly just use it for the furniture.

Could Play Without:
11. Wedding Stories - Just got this one, still need to explore.
12. Batuu - Too separate from everything else, doesn't integrate well with other packs.

Favorites tier:

1. Werewolves
2. Strangerville

Mid tier:

The ranking within this tier is subject to ups and downs.

3. Dine out (ironically after saying "Meh, I won't need this ever" for several years)
4. Jungle Adventure
5. Realm of Magic
6. Journey to Batuu
7. Spa Day
8. Outdoor Retreat
9. Vampires (they were the first occults to get added and were done great, but I don't enjoy the theme)

Only interested in the BB or world - tier:

10. My wedding stories
11. Parenthood
12. Dream Home Decorator