I love LGR for his wit and his intelligence. Since he is also a long time simmer, who has played all versions of the game, I trust his opinions because he has a great depth of knowledge (ie., he didn't just start playing the game with TS3 or whatever, like some of the younger gamechangers). I thought his Island Living review was very balanced, and I say that even though I am a bigger fan of the pack than he seemed to be. He did fairly acknowledge the aspects of the pack he enjoyed (like the world and the Off the Grid trait), while also pointing out the lack of depth (as he saw it) in certain things, like the merfolk, and diving (with the absence of a dive lot). The Moschino Stuff Pack review was very unenthusiastic, but he has never cared for stuff packs in any of the iterations of Sims; however, I thought his points were all valid. In order to understand how a skill works, like gardening or photography or whatever, I tend to watch someone like Carl, who does more 'how to' videos, which are different than reviews. Anyway, I really hope LGR continues to review the Sims; I'd really like to see him do some more Let's Plays as well, as his ones from the earlier games (TS1 and TS2) are hilarious.