Thanks so much to everyone who gave their opinion and voted. Kristyn Hopson clearly won and will now go on a romantic date with Nathan. But as I said, I really liked all of them so the others will be introduced to some other handsome bachelors in my game:
Alicia will meet aspiring author Patrick Kirkland. If everything goes well she will spend her life lazily reading his books on a little bench in the garden of their beautiful little home in Windenburg.
Joyce will be introduced to top athlete Troy Mason. And if they get along she will move into his mediterranean villa in Oasis Springs and lazily throw well catered parties.
If anyone is interested in giving one of these ladies a different story, I uploaded them as one household 'Eligible Bachelorettes'.