THREAD CLOSED
Now that time has passed, for those of you who got the pack, how are you liking it?
Forum Discussion
Now that time has passed, for those of you who got the pack, how are you liking it?
- Hey everyone, let's remember what this thread is about and go back to discussing Island Living while respecting each others opinions. ;)
"Beardedgeek;c-17151139" wrote:
"keekee53;c-17151129" wrote:
"Beardedgeek;c-17150909" wrote:
"jooxis;c-17150897" wrote:
I'm having trouble getting into it. I feel like I've already done everything that the pack offers in my first day of gameplay.
I feel this is easily the weakest expansion pack they have released so far in terms of gameplay and it is even weaker than most of the game packs in this regard which is alarming. And that makes me quite sad and not very hopeful about Realm of Magic.
I think it depends on what you consider "gameplay". I have been playing every day since this pack dropped and I still have tons of things to do.
Plus I just genuinely love what I have already done.
Spending every day snorkeling, free diving for seashells and doing yoga in the evenings... (who me? Jealous of my Sims? Nah...)
huh It is very clear fun is subjective because watching my sim swim around a buoy, watching bubble as they dive and then watching them finish the evening with yoga...I need more going on in my game for entertainment.
Apparently so.
I loathe interactive careers ( working from home I can deal with, but doctor or scientist? It's soooooo frustrating after awhile).
I also enjoy them doing similar tasks as snorkeling. Which is all the tasks.
I still don't get why snorkeling is wrongfully percieved as a "rabbit hole" when you have the exact same interactivity there as literally all other tasks. You can describe every action in the game like you describe snorkeling: workout? Check. Jogging? Check. Cooking? Check. Swimming in a pool? Check. Karaoke? Check.
Not sure if you are referring to me with the wrongfully perceived as a rabbit hole comment because I felt I was clear. Snorkling =swimming around the bouy Diving=rabbithole with bubbles.
You are right about the many actions are monotonous in game such as the ones you listed. However, I look at cooking as satisfying a Sim need. It is just like having my sim use the toilet or shower. It is not a real "feature" of some expansion pack. At the very least I can still choose my Sim's meal making it more interactive. Swimming is boring too and I am still waiting for some type of gameplay to be added there but it is seasonal in most neighborhoods. Karaoke I don't use but at least you can sing with other sims to make it more social and choose a song. With snorkling, I can't say hey look at the shell over there and grab it because we can't even go under the water. Sims 3 showed what diving should be...interactive. I could click and grab fish, open treasure boxes, possible run into a mermaid or shark, ran out of oxygen after a certain amount of time and had to head up, etc I was just genuinely surprised you would consider watching a sim swim around a buoy or watching dive bubbles as gameplay."MorriSan;c-17151248" wrote:
"drake_mccarty;c-17151171" wrote:
"Beardedgeek;c-17151139" wrote:
"keekee53;c-17151129" wrote:
"Beardedgeek;c-17150909" wrote:
"jooxis;c-17150897" wrote:
I'm having trouble getting into it. I feel like I've already done everything that the pack offers in my first day of gameplay.
I feel this is easily the weakest expansion pack they have released so far in terms of gameplay and it is even weaker than most of the game packs in this regard which is alarming. And that makes me quite sad and not very hopeful about Realm of Magic.
I think it depends on what you consider "gameplay". I have been playing every day since this pack dropped and I still have tons of things to do.
Plus I just genuinely love what I have already done.
Spending every day snorkeling, free diving for seashells and doing yoga in the evenings... (who me? Jealous of my Sims? Nah...)
huh It is very clear fun is subjective because watching my sim swim around a buoy, watching bubble as they dive and then watching them finish the evening with yoga...I need more going on in my game for entertainment.
Apparently so.
I loathe interactive careers ( working from home I can deal with, but doctor or scientist? It's soooooo frustrating after awhile).
I also enjoy them doing similar tasks as snorkeling. Which is all the tasks.
I still don't get why snorkeling is wrongfully percieved as a "rabbit hole" when you have the exact same interactivity there as literally all other tasks. You can describe every action in the game like you describe snorkeling: workout? Check. Jogging? Check. Cooking? Check. Swimming in a pool? Check. Karaoke? Check.
Clearly those referring to snorkeling as a rabbit hole are talking about diving. You know that, you’re just trying to play semantic games with it.
Snorkeling is just as thrilling as diving tho. Your sim swims around a small area and pop up’s tell you what they find. I mean at least they don’t disappear but it’s not like snorkeling is a super exciting activity that adds so many dimensions to the game. It’s like a different form of jogging, and I don’t consider that very entertaining to watch given the repetition in just one play through.
Semantic games? I didn't think beardedgeek plays them but hey, difference of view is a thing. We might both be wrong. You are aggresively trying to shove your opinion down other people's throats by throwing around your opinion as if it is some kind of ultimate truth. And you seem to be able to read thoughts.
Personally I consider snorkeling very different from jogging. I tend to scroll in until first person view and enjoy the gorgeous riff. Similar to real life. I'm not a sporty snorkeler, I do it for the vista. Which looks different depending on weather and daytime and the aquatic life that is around - Ingame and in real life.
No one is taking away from the pretty. I think we all can agree Sulani is pretty but is that gameplay?? This is the thing I was trying to understand because I personally don't think it is.
I didn't think @drake_mccarty was trying to sway or shove an opinion down someone's throat. As I always say everyone has an opinion and they are entitled to it. You are entitled to watch your sim swim around the buoy and love it."keekee53;c-17151582" wrote:
"Beardedgeek;c-17151139" wrote:
"keekee53;c-17151129" wrote:
"Beardedgeek;c-17150909" wrote:
"jooxis;c-17150897" wrote:
I'm having trouble getting into it. I feel like I've already done everything that the pack offers in my first day of gameplay.
I feel this is easily the weakest expansion pack they have released so far in terms of gameplay and it is even weaker than most of the game packs in this regard which is alarming. And that makes me quite sad and not very hopeful about Realm of Magic.
I think it depends on what you consider "gameplay". I have been playing every day since this pack dropped and I still have tons of things to do.
Plus I just genuinely love what I have already done.
Spending every day snorkeling, free diving for seashells and doing yoga in the evenings... (who me? Jealous of my Sims? Nah...)
huh It is very clear fun is subjective because watching my sim swim around a buoy, watching bubble as they dive and then watching them finish the evening with yoga...I need more going on in my game for entertainment.
Apparently so.
I loathe interactive careers ( working from home I can deal with, but doctor or scientist? It's soooooo frustrating after awhile).
I also enjoy them doing similar tasks as snorkeling. Which is all the tasks.
I still don't get why snorkeling is wrongfully percieved as a "rabbit hole" when you have the exact same interactivity there as literally all other tasks. You can describe every action in the game like you describe snorkeling: workout? Check. Jogging? Check. Cooking? Check. Swimming in a pool? Check. Karaoke? Check.
Not sure if you are referring to me with the wrongfully perceived as a rabbit hole comment because I felt I was clear. Snorkling =swimming around the bouy Diving=rabbithole with bubbles.
You are right about the many actions are monotonous in game such as the ones you listed. However, I look at cooking as satisfying a Sim need. It is just like having my sim use the toilet or shower. It is not a real "feature" of some expansion pack. At the very least I can still choose my Sim's meal making it more interactive. Swimming is boring too and I am still waiting for some type of gameplay to be added there but it is seasonal in most neighborhoods. Karaoke I don't use but at least you can sing with other sims to make it more social and choose a song. With snorkling, I can't say hey look at the shell over there and grab it because we can't even go under the water. Sims 3 showed what diving should be...interactive. I could click and grab fish, open treasure boxes, possible run into a mermaid or shark, ran out of oxygen after a certain amount of time and had to head up, etc I was just genuinely surprised you would consider watching a sim swim around a buoy or watching dive bubbles as gameplay.
It really sounds to me like you don't want to play Sims, you want to play Subnautica or something else similar. This IS the Sims gameplay. It has always BEEN the Sims gameplay. As for SIms 3 diving... that was the odd thing out in the entire game. It's like Jogging being interactive or whatever.
There is nothing different, at all, gameplay wise between the diving interaction and the weight lifting interaction or the train your dog fetch interaction. So again I am not sure why you expected that to be different."Simsister2004;c-17151461" wrote:
Yeah, darn it. There is always so much critisism of a really enjoyable game - for me that is. If you don't enjoy it buy and play another game, please! Nuf said. You just ruined my day!
Huh or you could not read the forums. I would hate to ruin your day. I put my opinions and feedback out there so the team can do better. This was not an acceptable expansion pack for me and if I could get my money back, I would."Beardedgeek;c-17151612" wrote:
"keekee53;c-17151582" wrote:
"Beardedgeek;c-17151139" wrote:
"keekee53;c-17151129" wrote:
"Beardedgeek;c-17150909" wrote:
"jooxis;c-17150897" wrote:
I'm having trouble getting into it. I feel like I've already done everything that the pack offers in my first day of gameplay.
I feel this is easily the weakest expansion pack they have released so far in terms of gameplay and it is even weaker than most of the game packs in this regard which is alarming. And that makes me quite sad and not very hopeful about Realm of Magic.
I think it depends on what you consider "gameplay". I have been playing every day since this pack dropped and I still have tons of things to do.
Plus I just genuinely love what I have already done.
Spending every day snorkeling, free diving for seashells and doing yoga in the evenings... (who me? Jealous of my Sims? Nah...)
huh It is very clear fun is subjective because watching my sim swim around a buoy, watching bubble as they dive and then watching them finish the evening with yoga...I need more going on in my game for entertainment.
Apparently so.
I loathe interactive careers ( working from home I can deal with, but doctor or scientist? It's soooooo frustrating after awhile).
I also enjoy them doing similar tasks as snorkeling. Which is all the tasks.
I still don't get why snorkeling is wrongfully percieved as a "rabbit hole" when you have the exact same interactivity there as literally all other tasks. You can describe every action in the game like you describe snorkeling: workout? Check. Jogging? Check. Cooking? Check. Swimming in a pool? Check. Karaoke? Check.
Not sure if you are referring to me with the wrongfully perceived as a rabbit hole comment because I felt I was clear. Snorkling =swimming around the bouy Diving=rabbithole with bubbles.
You are right about the many actions are monotonous in game such as the ones you listed. However, I look at cooking as satisfying a Sim need. It is just like having my sim use the toilet or shower. It is not a real "feature" of some expansion pack. At the very least I can still choose my Sim's meal making it more interactive. Swimming is boring too and I am still waiting for some type of gameplay to be added there but it is seasonal in most neighborhoods. Karaoke I don't use but at least you can sing with other sims to make it more social and choose a song. With snorkling, I can't say hey look at the shell over there and grab it because we can't even go under the water. Sims 3 showed what diving should be...interactive. I could click and grab fish, open treasure boxes, possible run into a mermaid or shark, ran out of oxygen after a certain amount of time and had to head up, etc I was just genuinely surprised you would consider watching a sim swim around a buoy or watching dive bubbles as gameplay.
It really sounds to me like you don't want to play Sims, you want to play Subnautica or something else similar. This IS the Sims gameplay. It has always BEEN the Sims gameplay. As for SIms 3 diving... that was the odd thing out in the entire game. It's like Jogging being interactive or whatever.
There is nothing different, at all, gameplay wise between the diving interaction and the weight lifting interaction or the train your dog fetch interaction. So again I am not sure why you expected that to be different.
Having played this game since Sims 1, I respectfully disagree. This is not the Sims gameplay from previous iterations. Snorkeling in a circle and dive bubbles are not the gameplay norm. You can't dismiss Sims 3 diving as an odd thing. It was a proper feature of the pack. I wasn't playing subnautica in Sims 3, I was enjoying a proper dive lot. Sims 4 diving was listed as feature but it is definitely not a proper feature for me.
There is a difference between interactive gameplay and skill based gameplay and maybe this is where the disconnect is between you and I. Jogging, Cooking, weight lifting, etc are all skill based. I am looking for the exploration and real time interactive gameplay that was in Sims 3 dive lots. At the VERY LEAST learn a skill to get to the interactive gameplay such as hidden lots. I would have even been happier if I had to get skilled in snorkeling before I could dive and have a certain level of fitness before I could snorkel."keekee53;c-17151648" wrote:
"Beardedgeek;c-17151612" wrote:
"keekee53;c-17151582" wrote:
"Beardedgeek;c-17151139" wrote:
"keekee53;c-17151129" wrote:
"Beardedgeek;c-17150909" wrote:
"jooxis;c-17150897" wrote:
I'm having trouble getting into it. I feel like I've already done everything that the pack offers in my first day of gameplay.
I feel this is easily the weakest expansion pack they have released so far in terms of gameplay and it is even weaker than most of the game packs in this regard which is alarming. And that makes me quite sad and not very hopeful about Realm of Magic.
I think it depends on what you consider "gameplay". I have been playing every day since this pack dropped and I still have tons of things to do.
Plus I just genuinely love what I have already done.
Spending every day snorkeling, free diving for seashells and doing yoga in the evenings... (who me? Jealous of my Sims? Nah...)
huh It is very clear fun is subjective because watching my sim swim around a buoy, watching bubble as they dive and then watching them finish the evening with yoga...I need more going on in my game for entertainment.
Apparently so.
I loathe interactive careers ( working from home I can deal with, but doctor or scientist? It's soooooo frustrating after awhile).
I also enjoy them doing similar tasks as snorkeling. Which is all the tasks.
I still don't get why snorkeling is wrongfully percieved as a "rabbit hole" when you have the exact same interactivity there as literally all other tasks. You can describe every action in the game like you describe snorkeling: workout? Check. Jogging? Check. Cooking? Check. Swimming in a pool? Check. Karaoke? Check.
Not sure if you are referring to me with the wrongfully perceived as a rabbit hole comment because I felt I was clear. Snorkling =swimming around the bouy Diving=rabbithole with bubbles.
You are right about the many actions are monotonous in game such as the ones you listed. However, I look at cooking as satisfying a Sim need. It is just like having my sim use the toilet or shower. It is not a real "feature" of some expansion pack. At the very least I can still choose my Sim's meal making it more interactive. Swimming is boring too and I am still waiting for some type of gameplay to be added there but it is seasonal in most neighborhoods. Karaoke I don't use but at least you can sing with other sims to make it more social and choose a song. With snorkling, I can't say hey look at the shell over there and grab it because we can't even go under the water. Sims 3 showed what diving should be...interactive. I could click and grab fish, open treasure boxes, possible run into a mermaid or shark, ran out of oxygen after a certain amount of time and had to head up, etc I was just genuinely surprised you would consider watching a sim swim around a buoy or watching dive bubbles as gameplay.
It really sounds to me like you don't want to play Sims, you want to play Subnautica or something else similar. This IS the Sims gameplay. It has always BEEN the Sims gameplay. As for SIms 3 diving... that was the odd thing out in the entire game. It's like Jogging being interactive or whatever.
There is nothing different, at all, gameplay wise between the diving interaction and the weight lifting interaction or the train your dog fetch interaction. So again I am not sure why you expected that to be different.
There is a difference between interactive gameplay and skill based gameplay
On the offchance of derailing this thread even more, I agree that there is a difference between doing things, in a way, and sort of watching things happen. As much as I like TS4, I still think it should move towards that interactive gameplay more whenever it has the chance to - and I think JA vs WA is a particularly good example of this. In 3 WA I actually have to push things around, stand on things, fail. It feels very interactive. In 4 JA, I kind of watch them study some things, then try pulling some stuff and tada, it works or it doesn't. But yes, that process is undeniably far less interactive. So even if I personally don't mind that diving isn't an active thing - this would've been one of those chances they definitely should have used. Just like I kind of wish that the tombs in JA were a tat more like those in WA. Simply because it was introduced in the most recent prior iteration and it makes sense for people to expect these things to come back. Just my 2 cents."Beardedgeek;c-17151430" wrote:
People have, indeed, called Snorkeling a rabbit hole activity. As for diving... I don't mind it.
Also, quotation marks? Really? You hate it that much? To the point that you fail to see all the gameplay... What exactly did you expect, I wonder?
Where is "all the gameplay"? You know what, never mind... what I expected was a layer of depth to keep me entertained for as long as Dine Out, City Living or Vampires did... Island Living does not deliver it and I'm not alone in thinking so. There is nothing NEW to do. I saw all the features in an hour."Beardedgeek;c-17151249" wrote:
"drake_mccarty;c-17151171" wrote:
"Beardedgeek;c-17151139" wrote:
"keekee53;c-17151129" wrote:
"Beardedgeek;c-17150909" wrote:
"jooxis;c-17150897" wrote:
I'm having trouble getting into it. I feel like I've already done everything that the pack offers in my first day of gameplay.
I feel this is easily the weakest expansion pack they have released so far in terms of gameplay and it is even weaker than most of the game packs in this regard which is alarming. And that makes me quite sad and not very hopeful about Realm of Magic.
I think it depends on what you consider "gameplay". I have been playing every day since this pack dropped and I still have tons of things to do.
Plus I just genuinely love what I have already done.
Spending every day snorkeling, free diving for seashells and doing yoga in the evenings... (who me? Jealous of my Sims? Nah...)
huh It is very clear fun is subjective because watching my sim swim around a buoy, watching bubble as they dive and then watching them finish the evening with yoga...I need more going on in my game for entertainment.
Apparently so.
I loathe interactive careers ( working from home I can deal with, but doctor or scientist? It's soooooo frustrating after awhile).
I also enjoy them doing similar tasks as snorkeling. Which is all the tasks.
I still don't get why snorkeling is wrongfully percieved as a "rabbit hole" when you have the exact same interactivity there as literally all other tasks. You can describe every action in the game like you describe snorkeling: workout? Check. Jogging? Check. Cooking? Check. Swimming in a pool? Check. Karaoke? Check.
Clearly those referring to snorkeling as a rabbit hole are talking about diving. You know that, you’re just trying to play semantic games with it.
Snorkeling is just as thrilling as diving tho. Your sim swims around a small area and pop up’s tell you what they find. I mean at least they don’t disappear but it’s not like snorkeling is a super exciting activity that adds so many dimensions to the game. It’s like a different form of jogging, and I don’t consider that very entertaining to watch given the repetition in just one play through.
So two things:
1. If you first try to correct me then say you don't find a reasonable difference, then your correction is pointless.
2. Why play the Sims if the default-for-all-interractions is boring to you? And has been in all Sims games, 1-4?
What exactly is “default for all”? This is an expansion pack and it should provide a hefty amount of *NEW* gameplay, *NEW* features, and new stuff. Snorkeling is supposedly one of the new gameplay features of this pack and I said it’s about as thrilling as going for a jog. Clearly you aren’t understanding what I’m saying. Whether that’s intentional or not, I don’t really know or care.
I corrected you because you were trying to create an argument based off your own misunderstanding. I’m not trying to get into a game of semantics with you, just clearing up some misinformation you are so gleefully spreading even though you knew what they meant. Other poster thinks I can read minds, no, I can read text on this website.
I really would like you to clarify a bit on that second bullet. It sounds like you are putting words on my mouth on that and I would like more details about what you mean before I respond to it. @Beardedgeek
ETA: @keekee53 you make such an excellent point with the interactive vs skill based gameplay!! You took the words right out of my mouth.- i'm really sad about rabbit holes this far in the sims franchise shouldn't be rabbit holes :s
