What Would You Do If The Accolade Presented Is A Different Color From the One Received?

You could be correct, but as you can see, the other shades show up and that picture was also taken in Live mode. I think what I may do, is go back and trade in the silver or bronze for gold and just keep two silvers (even though at the end of the Meet & Greet Events, he earned gold) just to differentiate between the categories. Thanks for weighing in on the subject. :)