Worst Sims Pack of all time

I was never, ever, able to use one thing from the Katy Perry stuff pack so that's the worst one ever. At least the SW SP has nice floors and objects!

KP ST is just a stuff pack

Neither of the two.

There's nothing redeemable about Katy Perry's Sweet Treats. Journey at least looks nice even if it has no substance.

Where is island living in the Choices?

I have not played either one, but my vote would go to JtB since it is a game pack that actually restricts players (removed inventory items, no magic or vampire powers, no buildable lots without cheats, limits on interactions with the NPCs, etc.), it has costume "aliens," & the only real gameplay appears to be repetitive quests with some variation between the 3 factions. I'm not against a SW pack in general & this pack could have been so much better.

"EternalSunshine;c-17735007" wrote:
I have not played either one, but my vote would go to JtB since it is a game pack that actually restricts players (removed inventory items, no magic or vampire powers, no buildable lots without cheats, limits on interactions with the NPCs, etc.), it has costume "aliens," & the only real gameplay appears to be repetitive quests with some variation between the 3 factions. I'm not against a SW pack in general & this pack could have been so much better.

agreed. i'm not into star wars stuff but man the pack could've been so much better, of course it was just a disney park advertisement, but if it actually was about the star wars franchise itself i know it would've been at least curious. and perhaps it could've gotten more people interested on star wars, which at the end is one of the goals of collabs. anyways ts4 lacks on every aspect of the game, not just this pack.
but i think one of the reasons the batuu pack is also hated is cuz it's about disney star wars which s*cks.

My first pet stuff

IMO Journey to Baatu is actually a good pack when it comes to buy/build. I may never take a Sim to Baatu or use the CAS items but build, buy and debug are worth a lot to me. IMO Parenthood and Seasons game play are not my thing. They changed the game for me. I had to start using mods to make the game work for my playing style. I rarely play kids and teens now because of Parenthood. Seasons did unspeakable things I am am not getting into now.

My First Pet Stuff should be in your poll.
Eco Living also because it does not work correctly. I was very excited for the pack. It's now disabled along with Dine Out.

Gardens are not possible with Eco Living because the plants revert to just planted when the environment changes. I can't keep the neighborhood industrial. I tried mods and they work but not for the gardening thing. To me the worst packs are the ones that I paid for but can't play.

I like journey to Batuu. I am still playing it and enjoying the fact that my sim can visit a galaxy far far away.

But perhaps it would have been better if this were a stand alone spin off because this is the first time the devs have actively tried NOT to integrate with other packs (no pets, weather, holiday traditions, regular inventory items on batuu and droids become remote control radios at home)
Once I am done playing, I will probably mainly use the light sabres to train fitness. And some of the build buy like the floors or the curved bar are useful.

I realise journey to Batuu is not for everyone but it adds something to do for your sims to do and to things to collect. unlike the Katy Perry pack. That one just adds 100 % useless stuff to the game. Now Katy Perry sweet treats, that is a pack I would not want to add to my game if I got it for free.