I voted for Cottage Living not because It is my favorite expansion ( I dont really vibe with the farming theme) but because I think it is an example of how an expansion pack should be made. The world is beautifull and full of stuff to do. The gameplay is replayable, not tedious at all and there is a lot of stuff to do If you re into farming. I really like high school too but I understand your decision to leave out because it is still new. I honestly think it is going to be my favourite expansion of all time. Of course, in terms of theme nothing can beat seasons because weather is that basic. That being said I dont think the actual holidays gameplay is that fun. I feel like seasons constanly gets undue credit for the sole reason that people need weather in their game.