Definitely a 10. Too late for me to vote though. Here is why I vote Island Living a 10.
The World is gorgeous.
The beaches and oceans are beautiful.
The numerous waterfalls plus the one you can bathe in,play in and woohoo in.
Sulani is one of only 2 worlds you can swim in the ocean with Tartosa being the 2nd. Other worlds are mainly swimmable lakes.
The Rentals. They look like real tropical builds everything from the doors,windows,ceiling fans etc.
Lots Being On The Water.
The Volcano.
3 Beaches
The 2 big empty lots. I'm planning on placing a Waterpark on one of them now that we have Splash Pads. Every beach get away should have a large waterpark.
Edit
I hope this isn't considered a necro thread cause it shouldn't be. I know it's old but I really wanted to point out some of the things I liked. I missed this thread until it was linked in the Growing Together Poll. If it is then I'll delete my comment. I don't want to get in trouble on here.