Sooo, here it is again, another edition of my "How do you rate ______"-thread.I purposefully waited for a little while this time, hoping that those who end up rating the pack have actually bought and played it for a bit, since the goal - as always - is for our ratings to help out others who are still on the fence about getting this pack. Since grouping the numbers together hasn't been so great for everyone last time, I've decided to add each number between 1 and 10 to the poll separately this time. Hope that's better.I will add my own thoughts and feelings in a comment later on, but let me just say that I think RoM is a really great pack - despite some minor inconveniences.So without further ado: on a scale from 1 to 10 - 1 being "I wish I could return this atrocity" and 10 being "Simtastic, best pack ever" - how would YOU rate Realm of Magic?

A solid 7 from me. It's not the "best pack evvahh", but definitely one of the better ones, and I feel I got what I paid for. :smile:

I myself would give it an 8. I love it a LOT, and think there's some really awesome stuff in it.Things I love:- I think it's cool that we can improve the quality of crafted items- In general, I'm in love with the practical magic stuff- The spells are, for the most part, really great- I love that mischief magic is a fun way to be mischievous (I tend to hate trying to have a mischievous sim, but with RoM it's way more fun)- I love that mischief FINALLY gives us an easy way to have negative character values for teens - it's always been so hard to have negative character values, so I'm very happy about this- The Realm is super pretty and even better with a bit of extra editing- I know others have said that magic is way too easy but I've now played for +- 15 hours and I haven't been able to max out any sim in anything yet. Maybe my game is buggy cause they don't learn potions from experimenting on the cauldron, and they don't learn spells from practicing magic (at least not fast? I think one of them has learned something this way, but I may be imagining that). But either way, I like it this way! I think learning magic is well-balanced, and well I honestly don't want it to be super difficult either, cause if it was I'd probably only do it once or twice, since it would take way too much time.- I love the different schools of magic and that I can focus on having my sims learn only one type of magic (mischief / untamed / practical), or alchemy, or both, or multiple ones. It allows me to create very different kinds of spellcasters and that's awesome!- I love that it makes gardening / collecting / herbalism way more fun and useful- Familiars follow teens to school as far as I can tell, which is greatThings I wish they had included:- For Scruberoo to also clean litterboxes, laundry, etc. That would've been really cool.- More recipes, drinks, etc. would've been nice- Two editable lots in the Realm - HQ & a bar or magical restaurant or something like that- Kids and toddler items- Kids and toddler magic (but I'm VERY happy kids can have familiars at least)- Yeah, the houses should be better, I do agree with this. I don't care THAT much, but like HQ at least should be fully and completely built and pretty, since, in theory, we shouldn't be able to live there or edit it .. so I feel that at least that one should have been way more complete- No cabinets - I mean why?? WHY? WHY?????- A bit more cross-pack compatible spells would've been neat, even if I'm very happy with the spells we did getI'm sure I'm forgetting some things but overall, this sums it up.Again, it's a super nice pack. I am so happy I have my witches back, but since this is the most important pack to me after Seasons, I am more critical about it than, say, an IL pack because I simply don't need islands and beaches. But for the fact that my hopes and expectations were so high, RoM definitely met them and, at least in some areas, exceeded them. I wish that next time they make it an EP again though, because there's so much more we could've gotten, but it's a very decent GP. :)

https://i.pinimg.com/originals/e5/b0/22/e5b0224150e6ca410cef197021e0bc75.gifI’m feeling generous today.I’ve talked myself into the delusion that It has potential, I hope to see this pack built off of in many ways as we continue. But right now I would call the Realm of Magic a solid foundation to magic.As we go on, and mods and other content releases I think it could be better but alone... ther other content cas, build buy, is okay, i’m Not going to use it, i don’t think, I love Glimmerbrook and I haven’t even fully explored it yet, I peaked my head through the portal and turned around, but this isn’t enough in terms of magic and spells. Magic itself was suppose to be the central focus, an abundance spells and potions. Personally I feel like they could have scrapped some stuff if it meant more spells.

If the bugs werent a nuisance this would get an 8 from me. I wanna start selling potions already!It's good having another occult as developed as vampires. Personally, occults should just have their own packs instead of being shoehorned into others. The gameplay is keeping me interested, and also got me to do things ingame I dont usually pay attention to. I wont say this is my favorite GP, but its worth the money. But these bugs gotta get fixed soon.

Your Realm of Magic Rating | EA Forums

72 Replies

Nielsern75
6 years ago
A solid 7 from me. It's not the "best pack evvahh", but definitely one of the better ones, and I feel I got what I paid for. :smile:
Joanne_Snow
Legend
6 years ago
I myself would give it an 8. I love it a LOT, and think there's some really awesome stuff in it.

Things I love:
- I think it's cool that we can improve the quality of crafted items
- In general, I'm in love with the practical magic stuff
- The spells are, for the most part, really great
- I love that mischief magic is a fun way to be mischievous (I tend to hate trying to have a mischievous sim, but with RoM it's way more fun)
- I love that mischief FINALLY gives us an easy way to have negative character values for teens - it's always been so hard to have negative character values, so I'm very happy about this
- The Realm is super pretty and even better with a bit of extra editing
- I know others have said that magic is way too easy but I've now played for +- 15 hours and I haven't been able to max out any sim in anything yet. Maybe my game is buggy cause they don't learn potions from experimenting on the cauldron, and they don't learn spells from practicing magic (at least not fast? I think one of them has learned something this way, but I may be imagining that). But either way, I like it this way! I think learning magic is well-balanced, and well I honestly don't want it to be super difficult either, cause if it was I'd probably only do it once or twice, since it would take way too much time.
- I love the different schools of magic and that I can focus on having my sims learn only one type of magic (mischief / untamed / practical), or alchemy, or both, or multiple ones. It allows me to create very different kinds of spellcasters and that's awesome!
- I love that it makes gardening / collecting / herbalism way more fun and useful
- Familiars follow teens to school as far as I can tell, which is great

Things I wish they had included:
- For Scruberoo to also clean litterboxes, laundry, etc. That would've been really cool.
- More recipes, drinks, etc. would've been nice
- Two editable lots in the Realm - HQ & a bar or magical restaurant or something like that
- Kids and toddler items
- Kids and toddler magic (but I'm VERY happy kids can have familiars at least)
- Yeah, the houses should be better, I do agree with this. I don't care THAT much, but like HQ at least should be fully and completely built and pretty, since, in theory, we shouldn't be able to live there or edit it .. so I feel that at least that one should have been way more complete
- No cabinets - I mean why?? WHY? WHY?????
- A bit more cross-pack compatible spells would've been neat, even if I'm very happy with the spells we did get

I'm sure I'm forgetting some things but overall, this sums it up.

Again, it's a super nice pack. I am so happy I have my witches back, but since this is the most important pack to me after Seasons, I am more critical about it than, say, an IL pack because I simply don't need islands and beaches. But for the fact that my hopes and expectations were so high, RoM definitely met them and, at least in some areas, exceeded them. I wish that next time they make it an EP again though, because there's so much more we could've gotten, but it's a very decent GP. :)
MasonGamerBoi
6 years ago
https://i.pinimg.com/originals/e5/b0/22/e5b0224150e6ca410cef197021e0bc75.gif

I’m feeling generous today.

I’ve talked myself into the delusion that It has potential, I hope to see this pack built off of in many ways as we continue. But right now I would call the Realm of Magic a solid foundation to magic.

As we go on, and mods and other content releases I think it could be better but alone... ther other content cas, build buy, is okay, i’m Not going to use it, i don’t think, I love Glimmerbrook and I haven’t even fully explored it yet, I peaked my head through the portal and turned around, but this isn’t enough in terms of magic and spells. Magic itself was suppose to be the central focus, an abundance spells and potions. Personally I feel like they could have scrapped some stuff if it meant more spells.
Joanne_Snow
Legend
6 years ago
"MasonGamer;c-17243953" wrote:
https://i.pinimg.com/originals/e5/b0/22/e5b0224150e6ca410cef197021e0bc75.gif

I’ve feeling generous today generous

I’ve talked myself into the delusion that It has potential, I hope to see this pack built off of in many ways as we continue. But right now I would call the Realm of Magic the foundation to magic.

As we go on, and mods and other content releases I think it could be better but alone... this isn’t enough in terms of magic and spells.

I saw your comment in another thread about perhaps adding in more spells as we get other content, and I sincerely hope they'd consider doing that. Cause that would be really neat, if say, they'd get a "studious" spell when uni comes out. I doubt it, but it'd be kinda cool :D
MasonGamerBoi
6 years ago
"SimTrippy;c-17243957" wrote:
"MasonGamer;c-17243953" wrote:
https://i.pinimg.com/originals/e5/b0/22/e5b0224150e6ca410cef197021e0bc75.gif

I’ve feeling generous today generous

I’ve talked myself into the delusion that It has potential, I hope to see this pack built off of in many ways as we continue. But right now I would call the Realm of Magic the foundation to magic.

As we go on, and mods and other content releases I think it could be better but alone... this isn’t enough in terms of magic and spells.

I saw your comment in another thread about perhaps adding in more spells as we get other content, and I sincerely hope they'd consider doing that. Cause that would be really neat, if say, they'd get a "studious" spell when uni comes out. I doubt it, but it'd be kinda cool :D

Yeah i’m Not talking like a trope of spells but a couple would be nice.
WolfNate
6 years ago
I have like 4 critiques but mostly love it
Fluteline24
Seasoned Ace
6 years ago
It's the best game pack. :)
Daermor
6 years ago
I love spellcasters, but the quality of this pack is really raw. It could be much better. So... 7.
DaWaterRat
Seasoned Ace
6 years ago
I waffled between a 7 and an 8, but in the end the gameplay (which is very fun) pushed it to an 8.

I mean, I can see where they could have done so much more, and I'm not sure how much of it was lack of time and how much was lack of priority, but I'm having so much fun with this pack, and I can fix much of what's lackluster in building myself - which yes, maybe I shouldn't have to, but I don't mind doing it.

So the two points off are for the things they could have done but didn't that I can't fix (without mods in some cases, apparently)
InuMiroLover
Seasoned Ace
6 years ago
If the bugs werent a nuisance this would get an 8 from me. I wanna start selling potions already!

It's good having another occult as developed as vampires. Personally, occults should just have their own packs instead of being shoehorned into others. The gameplay is keeping me interested, and also got me to do things ingame I dont usually pay attention to. I wont say this is my favorite GP, but its worth the money. But these bugs gotta get fixed soon.