Help with Eye Shape Preset Bug

Hi so after an update a month or two ago, my CC eye shape presets have been broken. Unlike EA eye shapes where they don't fully close when blinking to avoid clipping, the CC presets I have blink too fully and the eyelids clip into themselves. I only use one set of eye shape presets ("visions" by evoxyr), so I originally thought it was an issue with just those since they're like 5 years old,  but a couple days ago, I downloaded some that were created just a couple months ago to test it and those ones have the same issue.

I have tried everything I can think of to fix this issue: 50/50, redownloading the files, deleting caches, repairing the game, S4S batch fixes (though I only did the toddler patch eye batch fix), but this issue is still there. I even tried finding a tutorial to just remake them, but there were no tutorials for eye shape presets that I could find.

I haven't seen anyone else with this issue, so I really have no idea how to find a solution. I'm primarily a CAS player, so this really kills the experience for me honestly. I've had the evoxyr presets for years, so it's hard to believe they just broke on me all of a sudden. I've attached a photo of the issue: my Sim with all of my CC in the game. CC lashes make the issue more obvious looking, hence why this is such a problem for me.

If anyone has any sort of solution, it'd be such a great help! Thank you in advance!