ARAMSEY07 The only way to recover your old DLC is to recover your old account. EA customer support has a procedure for this: You'd need to answer some questions about the old account's details. It would help a lot to have purchase-related information on hand.
https://help.ea.com/en/customer-care/
You'll need to use live chat for this. If you don't see the option, try proceeding without signing into the site (you can use a private browsing window) and say you can't login to your account.
I got my account back. Thank you so much!
