Is Star Wars the best game pack ever for the Sims?

I've actually seen some positive comments on YouTube and there's a lot positive on Twitter too. In fact more recently, since the initial hate seemed to die off after the release. It just depends where you look and what you choose to surround yourself with. I'm sure if I looked I could find all of the negative stuff too but that doesn't mean that the positive isn't there also. ;)

Not at all. People seem to be dragging TS4 more than ever since this pack was announced. Of course what’s “best” would differ from person to person but I’ve seen a lot of people who say they’re enjoying it be like “it’s lacking...and I wish I could do...” and a whole other list of criticisms just to end it with “but despite all those shortcomings I still enjoy it :) “ so... definitely not the best from what I’m seeing.

Sims 4 Batuu goes well with Get to Work & Strangerville. It's weird & funny just like the
Base Rocket Ships/Cowplant. Just like the
Alien Abductions/Male pregnancies.
And, just like the Motherplant/Minions zombies.

Basically, we've had weird & funny since 2014.

"Onverser;c-17663003" wrote:

"Zeldaboy180;c-17662556" wrote:
this pack has been horribly received and the reviews are almost all negative

Nope, the positivity thread is thriving and is 63 pages long with over 1600 comments. :)

It has almost twice as many comments as the complaining thread which was started around the same time.

LOL whether the pack is good or not, these are some real politician numbers. “One third of people like us!” means TWO THIRDS DON’T

The Positivity thread may have double the posts, but it has 25% less views than the Complaints thread. 50% more content but a quarter less views is a curious metric. So the Complaints thread is either ranked higher on Google, is more relevant to the mood, or a smaller number of folks are talking amongst themselves in the Positivity thread. ??‍♀️

Who knows maybe one day EA will have the rocks to release pack sales numbers so we can know once and for all!

No, it's not the best in my opinion. When a pack can out do Makin' Magic, Superstar, and possibly TS3's Seasons, then it can toot it's horn. Until any pack surpasses Makin' Magic and Superstar, then no, none of them can live up to those standards. Any of them may have nice things about them I might like or not, but until Maxis can out do Makin' Magic and Superstar then no none of them are ever going to live up to those. The bar is high. ETA: I'm not talking about the theme but the gameplay and depth, in those packs and what made them very special. Look around, where do you see that these days? Not at such a high standard and or depth in complicated gameplay that takes some thought.

I think Star Wars JtB was one of the greatest packs in the history of Sims 4.
https://i.imgflip.com/p0lif.jpg
YAY YAY YAY YAY YAY...

I am in no way opposed to this pack, but my personal all time fav is island living

My favorite changes depending on what I'm doing in game. :p

My fave Gamepacks:
1. Vampires
2. Realm of Magic
3. Jungle Adventure
4. Spa Day
5. Star Wars
6. Strangerville

"Onverser;c-17663003" wrote:

"Zeldaboy180;c-17662556" wrote:
this pack has been horribly received and the reviews are almost all negative

Nope, the positivity thread is thriving and is 63 pages long with over 1600 comments. :)

It has almost twice as many comments as the complaining thread which was started around the same time.

I am too lazy to check, but I wonder how many negative comments got removed, which never seems to happen to positive comments even in cases where the commenter is being rude. Wonder why that is??