Forum Discussion

uglybuffys18's avatar
uglybuffys18
Seasoned Adventurer
7 days ago

The Marketplace ownership system is confusing and needs to be improved

I honestly think the Marketplace ownership system needs some serious improvement, especially when it comes to kits purchased through different platforms and currencies.

If you're going to offer kits through both Moola and real money (Cash), there should be a proper system in place to recognize ownership across all platforms. Why is it possible for me to own a kit one day, have it show as unowned the next, and then suddenly have it show as owned again? Why am I even being given the option to repurchase something I've already paid for?

I know the response to this is usually that this is how the system is designed and not a bug, but honestly, that doesn't make it any less confusing or poorly implemented.

For example, the Country Kitchen Kit showed as unowned in the in-game Marketplace just two days ago. Today, it shows as owned again in the Marketplace, but the EA app says I don't own it, even though the kit is literally installed in my game and accessible.

On top of that, all the kits I've purchased with Cash appear as unowned when I look at their Moola versions. So even though I already own the exact same content, the Marketplace doesn't seem to recognize that ownership across the different payment options.

How does that make any sense from a customer's perspective?

If I've paid for a product, I expect the platform to recognize that I own it. I shouldn't have to guess which storefront recognizes my purchase today, worry about accidentally buying something twice, or deal with conflicting ownership information between the EA app and the in-game Marketplace.

I think a much simpler solution would be to have a single kit page with clearly displayed purchasing options: EA app, website Marketplace, or in-game Marketplace, with the respective payment methods (Cash or Moola). And, most importantly, if you already own that kit through any of these options, it should simply say OWNED. That's it.

We're talking about a system that should be able to recognize whether a customer owns a digital product. I think we have the technology for that.

I love being able to access and purchase content for The Sims 4, but the current system makes something that should be straightforward unnecessarily messy and frustrating. Please consider improving cross-platform ownership recognition and making the purchasing experience more transparent for players.

1 Reply

  • HshXuk's avatar
    HshXuk
    Seasoned Novice
    8 hours ago

    I'll reply the same opinion here

    I completely agree with you.

    When I contacted EA Support about this issue, the advisor initially told me that Kits purchased through the in-game Marketplace should automatically sync with the EA app, and that they had never encountered a case like mine before.

    However, there are already multiple posts on the EA Forums from other users experiencing the same issue. Separately, I recently asked about this in another community, and some users reported that certain Kits purchased through the Marketplace were correctly marked as owned in the EA app, while others were missing.

    When I brought up the existing EA Forum posts, the advisor suddenly changed their explanation. They then told me that the EA app and the in-game Marketplace are operated by different parties, and that this behavior was therefore normal.

    So why did they initially insist that purchases should sync automatically and that my case was something they had never encountered before?

    I understand that the two storefronts have different operators. But from a customer’s perspective, they’re both part of the EA ecosystem and linked to the same EA account.

    And if the storefronts operate separately, why can we purchase Moola through the EA app to spend in the in-game Marketplace?

    Either integrate the two storefronts properly or make sure purchase ownership syncs reliably in both directions. Customers shouldn’t have to manually keep track of purchases just to avoid accidentally buying the same content twice.

    Let’s not forget that back in the Origin days, it was possible to register certain games purchased through Steam on Origin using their product keys. We had ways to link ownership across two entirely different platforms.

    Yet somehow, in 2026, EA can’t consistently synchronize purchase ownership between two storefronts within its own ecosystem, both linked to the same EA account? How does that make any sense? lol

    If cross-platform ownership registration was possible years ago, why should customers accept inconsistent purchase records within EA’s own ecosystem today?

    This isn’t an isolated incident, and the fact that the storefronts have different operators doesn’t excuse the problem.

    EA needs to stop brushing this issue aside with contradictory explanations, take responsibility, and actually fix it. Customers deserve a real solution, not excuses.