Ideas

Nico198x6's avatar
Nico198x6
Seasoned Newcomer
2 months ago

Player Carrer Mode - Personality Contradictions

Personality points continue accumulating indefinitely during Player Career, causing personality percentages to keep changing throughout the career.

Because personality-based PlayStyles require the player to maintain a specific current personality percentage, previously available PlayStyles can eventually become unavailable again.

The problem is made significantly worse by the way personality points are awarded during matches: even when deliberately trying to maximize one personality, normal match actions automatically generate large amounts of points for the other personalities.

This means there is no realistic way to maintain certain personality percentages while playing normally.

My example:

I created my current CAM with already 60.000 personality points:

60% Freigeist/Maverick

After approximately 1.5 seasons, this has already fallen to:

56% Freigeist/Maverick

I manually added all personality points currently displayed by the game and reached:

68,671 total personality points

Therefore personality progression does not stop at 60,000 points. The total continues increasing and the percentage distribution continues changing.

This creates a serious long-term progression problem because my Maverick PlayStyles require maintaining the relevant percentage.

If my percentage eventually falls below the required threshold, PlayStyles that were already available to my player become unavailable.

Why this cannot realistically be prevented

My player is a CAM using the Magician archetype.

His normal role involves:

  • passing
  • creating chances
  • assisting
  • combining with teammates
  • dribbling
  • making attacking runs
  • scoring

Normal football actions generate large amounts of Teamwork and Discipline personality points.

I specifically tested whether I could prevent my maverick percentage from declining by deliberately changing the way I played.

In one extreme test, I almost completely stopped passing and intentionally concentrated on dribbling, skill moves, solo runs and long-range goals.

The match still awarded approximately:

Freigeist/Maverick: 192
Discipline: 181
Teamwork: 48

That means I received approximately 192 points for the personality I was deliberately trying to maximize versus 229 combined points for the other two personalities.

This means that even while deliberately playing in an unrealistic way designed specifically to maximize maverick, I still could not generate more maverick points than the other two personalities combined.

Playing normally as a creative CAM makes the problem even worse because passing and combination play generate additional points outside maverick.

Expected behavior:

There should be a viable way to maintain or develop the selected personality through normal gameplay.

More importantly, PlayStyles that have already been unlocked should not later become unavailable simply because a continuously changing personality percentage falls below an arbitrary threshold.

Possible solutions would include:

  1. Make personality PlayStyle thresholds permanent unlock conditions. Once 25%, 50% or 65% has been achieved, the corresponding PlayStyle remains unlocked.
  2. Stop personality percentages changing after personality progression has been completed.
  3. Rebalance match personality rewards so that deliberately playing according to one personality can actually increase or at least maintain that personality percentage.
  4. Separate learned football abilities from continuously changing personality percentages.

Actual behavior:

Personality points continue accumulating indefinitely.

Normal gameplay automatically distributes significant points across multiple personalities.

As a result, my maverick percentage has already dropped from approximately 60% to 56% in 1.5 seasons.

There is no realistic gameplay method available to prevent the decline while continuing to play my position correctly.

This means my existing personality-based PlayStyles are effectively on a countdown until the percentage falls below their requirements.

Why this is game-breaking:

This makes long-term Player Career progression self-defeating.

My player can become a better and more complete footballer over several seasons while simultaneously losing access to abilities he previously possessed.

The only apparent way to fight against this is to stop playing normal football, lower the difficulty and repeatedly farm personality-specific actions.

A long-term career mode should reward player development, not require players to manipulate a percentage system simply to prevent their existing abilities from disappearing.

Please investigate the continued accumulation of personality points, personality reward distribution during matches, and the loss of previously available PlayStyles when personality percentages decline.

No CommentsBe the first to comment

Featured Places

Node avatar for FC 26 Bug Reports

FC 26 Bug Reports

Report bugs and see what the EA Sports FC 26 community is saying on this forum.Latest Activity: 3 days ago
11,791 Posts