[HSY] Teen Sim Fails to Become Valedictorian Despite Meeting Requirements

Okay, bridging first..

I discovered that a Teen Sim must have a Grade A in high school, a maxed performance bar, ace the exam, and age up within a week (by Saturday) to become Valedictorian. I successfully applied this to three Sims in my main save file (it's not vanilla, mods/CC installed). These three Sims always gave Valedictorian speeches at graduation.

The somehow, I recently encountered a bug with two of my teen Sims:

• Case 1: Sim "X" became Valedictorian upon aging up, but at the graduation ceremony, another Sim had the "Valedictorian" tag, and my Sim didn’t give the speech. This persists in the same patch as a previous success. I don't have pict for this case, cuz I just "okay let it go, he still got a Valedictorian trait tho"

• Case 2: Sim "Y" met all requirements (Grade A, maxed performance, "aced it" moodlet), aging up the same day with the buff active, but received a pop-up stating she graduated with honors instead. This disappointed me so much :( cuz she is the last teen Sim, so I played with her until she maxed out the age bar. Pict attached below

Steps to Reproduce: Ensure Teen Sim has Grade A, maxed performance bar, and "aced it" moodlet -> Age up Sim within a week of the exam (by Saturday) -> Observe the pop-up window -> attend the graduation, check every Sim tag, wait until valedictorian speech sessions.

Expected Result: Sim becomes Valedictorian and gives a speech at graduation.

Actual Result:

• Case 1: Another Sim takes Valedictorian tag/speech.
• Case 2: Sim graduates with honors despite meeting criteria.

Platform: PC

Game Version: 1.116.240.1020 DX11

Mods/CC: Yes, this is my main save file. I can give you my save, but some Sim will lose their CAS CC (Hair & make-up). 

Aditional Notes: This issue is confusing as conditions (patch, mods/CC) remain unchanged from successful cases, so I think using Mods/CC not much impacted the bug. Any insight or fix would be appreciated

Thank you!