[LD][RL]Soul fishing in Mourningvale isn't working

First of all, English is not my first language; I am using translation software to communicate.

When a Sim is in the Reaper career, they are supposed to be able to "Fish for Souls" at fishing spots in Mourningvale. 

However, the item that actually appears in the inventory after fishing is this:

While I must admit that having a guaranteed way to obtain Crystal Slippers is nice, this is clearly a bug.

To confirm this, I have already tested the game after removing all mods and starting a completely new save file, and the issue persists.