Nah dude. His shield is immediately shredded. Having shield only on ADS means his movement is severely restricted, meaning either Gibraltar has to be camping, dash shoot. or just standing still like an idiot to get his shield up. Most of the time, he's just lasered from behind. And I heard you mention his "slightly" and "unnoticeable" bigger hitbox. That's one of the points that I totally disagree with. Sure, a 60 hp shield can change the tide of the battle. Will Gibraltar have that shield open constantly 24/7 though? No. He'll have to move and change position. By the time he does that, *boom boom*. Now, his hitbox: he is the easiest target. Ever. I'm constantly landing all shotgun shots by dash scoping. Same for when I play as him: people laser me lmao. He can't even peek, cuz his enormous body frame peeks out as well. So his passive is pretty balanced. It makes up for his insanely large body frame. Returning your words back to you in a different way, a 50% bigger body-frame can mean life or death. P.S.- Since his body is so big, so is his shield. Easy to laser his shield. Agreeing with someone else, I would immediately offer up his shield for a smaller frame.