I disagree. I would consider them to be some of the most defensive legends in the game.
I personally have been maining rampart this season and have gotten 3k kills on her total, and just like most defensive legends currently, yes she has a minigun that is offensive, but she is still a defence-based legend. Gibraltar's and Caustic's ultimate's are very offensive too but having them be put in the offensive class for that doesn't make sense. It isn't just the abilities that constitutes a legends class, its their playstyle.
Wattson I can see being supportive but the same as Gibraltar and Newcastle, just because these legends have abilities that heal or revive teammates easier in a supportive way doesn't mean they are in the support class. The generator for wattson although healing teammates overtime, the purpose of it is to defend an area for longer by destroying granades and healing teammates who were shot so they can continue to defend in that area. So it all comes back to playstyle. And if you watch the ALGs all these defensive legends are able to lock areas down (which is the purpose of them).
I do see where you are coming from as the ability categories overlap but it's weighing up whether the legends actually belong in them categories based on their playstyle
I see where you're coming from as I agree. I don't think caustic is very good at defending for me personally since his traps are so counterable by simply shooting them.
Though, if you've watched the ALGS or High level players, Caustic is one of the most picked legends as he provides a very safe environment for the team to defend. I think he is a hard defence legend to master and doesn't hold much value in low skill games since you often don't need to fully defend like in the ALGS. However, with that being said, with caustic being good in High level but underwhelming in low level play, it would be difficult for respawn to give sizable buffs and nerfs for him. But guaranteed he will continue to be a defence legend and there is no need for switching him to another category as you've said he doesn't fit in any of them.
I think respawn is taking a new approach (similar to seer being a High level scan legend and bloodhound a low level scan legend) with that some legends although appearing useless of underpowered, are very powerful in specific setting such as the ALGS and so they may not get much play by the majority of players (Mad Maggie and Newcastle) but are used frequently by High level players.
Community ManagerCommunity Manager
