Ranked SBMM
I understand the reasoning behind SBMM, and I think it makes sense in pubs, but not ranked. I know It’s to help new players against smurfs, but that’s part of the game. Respectfully, if ranked worked...
Forum Discussion
@CapedCrusader42
You've hit on several different factors that make rank grinding a misery, but you have to remember that they call it a "grind" for a reason.
And there is nothing on your list that gets better if sbmm is removed. It only gets worse. With issue #2, for example, you're not calling out a failure of sbmm - you're calling out the failure of every single team-based shooter that ever existed. People of disparate skills playing on the same team is always a problem. In your example you think your lower-skilled buddy has it easy because he's currently higher ranked than you. But remember for a moment that when he plays with you he's in lobbies he can't handle. And if you and the other guy are just carrying him then very, very soon things will start to go poorly for him whether he queues with you or solos. These things are self-leveling, given enough time. Believe me when I say, nobody gets a free ride in this game regardless of rank or skill. Except cheaters. Which is a whole other problem we don't need to get into.
You've hit on several different factors that make rank grinding a misery, but you have to remember that they call it a "grind" for a reason.
And there is nothing on your list that gets better if sbmm is removed. It only gets worse. With issue #2, for example, you're not calling out a failure of sbmm - you're calling out the failure of every single team-based shooter that ever existed. People of disparate skills playing on the same team is always a problem. In your example you think your lower-skilled buddy has it easy because he's currently higher ranked than you. But remember for a moment that when he plays with you he's in lobbies he can't handle. And if you and the other guy are just carrying him then very, very soon things will start to go poorly for him whether he queues with you or solos. These things are self-leveling, given enough time. Believe me when I say, nobody gets a free ride in this game regardless of rank or skill. Except cheaters. Which is a whole other problem we don't need to get into.
Hi! Thank you for your response. While I totally understand and agree about it being a grind, my issue is with the subgrouping within ranked. Here is an excerpt from EA about the new ranked system:
- We are in the process of retiring our old Skill Based Matchmaking (SBMM) system for a new one that more accurately groups our players based on skill, and thus lets our matchmaking algorithm make better decisions when forming groups. The end goal is to create fairer matches and experiences that are more fun for all.
My concern is that if lower skilled people are paired in easier lobbies, they can make it farther than better players with just more time, not more skill. Similarly, higher skilled players are consistently grouped with high skilled players, even in lower levels. That Isn’t a true representation of your rank.
- @CapedCrusader42
"My concern is that if lower skilled people are paired in easier lobbies, they can make it farther than better players with just more time, not more skill. Similarly, higher skilled players are consistently grouped with high skilled players, even in lower levels. That Isn’t a true representation of your rank."
Your concern is legitimate if you believe that most lower skill players will remain lower skill forever. And that's not usually the case. Most of them will improve over time and start moving up the ladder. How far they move and how fast they get there is another issue. But it doesn't sound at all to me as if Respawn is attempting to assess skill early in the season and then just lock a player into perpetually easy or hard lobbies based on that early experience. It sounds like they're trying to match teams in the same way they match lobbies, which is to say all three teammates or roughly equal skill. I'll believe that when I see it. - @CapedCrusader42 Just ask yourself the question :
If the SBMM Blogpost from Samy Duc would reflect the InGame Reality ... why are there still so many rants on this Forum about the Matchmaking ?
Simple Answer : The Blogpost doesnt reflect the InGame reality ...Thank you for taking the time to read and respond. I know I’ve said a lot, but what drove me to write this (in hopes respawn sees this) is I’m just pointing out a discrepancy in skill in my actual game play with my friends. Said friend is Plat 3, has over 100 games more than me on the season and does decent damage in games (600-800+) when playing alone (he sends screenshots). However, when he plays with me in my current “Gold 3” lobbies, he barely does 200-300 damage and doesn’t usually win 1v1s.
He has always been stuck in Gold before SBMM but with the addition of SBMM, he is in Plat and has hit Diamond. This shows that even though he hasn’t been progressing in skill (with all love and respect, he hasn’t), he’s able to progress his rank anyway because SBMM is pairing him with other lower skilled players and his rank isn’t an actual representation of his skill, it’s more just a representation of how long he plays.
Meanwhile, a more skilled player in silver and gold is hitting a wall due to their higher SBMM rating pairing them with better players vs using their actual rank to match players together. If rank actually represented your skill, you wouldn’t need to have a background SBMM operating in addition to your rank, right? You could just use placement matches to start everyone at different ranks at the begging of the season and fill lobbies by rank +/- 1 tier if needed.
Community Highlights
- EA_Mako5 months ago
Community Manager
- EA_Mako6 months ago
