Switching heals on console

When opening up the heal items wheel to switch my heals it won’t let me switch to anything because I was moving the right stick too early I assume. Sometimes if I let go of the right stick it resets and I can select again. But not always, maybe because there is still a slight stick drift and so it’s still reading input. Most of the time I have to close out of the menu and open it back up being very careful not to move the right stick until the menu is fully open. I’ve had this problem for a long time now and I’m getting kind of frustrated that it’s not fixed yet.