@Palette24carats You are ignoring the biggest factor. #4 is the biggest difference between percentages, and it's very telling. That data is from ALGS, so at the Pro level. MnK should be dominating, it's only because of Aim Assist that controllers are viable at that level.
I keep saying this. Controllers do not need to compete with MnK on the same level. If Aim Assist is tuned to where it can compete or out perform a mouse, then it's over tuned. You're taking an input device that is natively very inaccurate compared to a mouse, but then making it better and more consistent.
If you pick "a tiny joystick" on PC, that's your choice. You shouldn't be rewarded for that.