Forum Discussion

reconzero's avatar
reconzero
Seasoned Ace
9 months ago

Timmy & Hal on the state of the game

https://www.dexerto.com/apex-legends/imperialhal-iitztimmy-claim-rankeds-biggest-flaw-may-be-killing-apex-legends-2984308/

Proving, at least to me, that they sort of get it. And they sort of don't.

They get that predator three stacks in ranked represent a problem to solo queue players. Hal's answer, to break out the lobbies by solo/duo/full stack, shows me that he doesn't understand the problems of a declining player base, or how this breakout would lead to longer queue times, or he just doesn't care about longer queue times. A point on which I'm fairly certain he's alone. Players say they'd be willing to wait longer for better matches, but every dev on the planet has data to prove that just isn't true over all. Which is why they all insist on 30 second max queue times no matter the cost in the quality of the match.

They both also see a content problem in the game. I see it too, though I'm not sure if we're really seeing the same problem at all. I see a lot of small changes (like the multiple pages of the season 23 update notes) that add up more to the appearance of change than to change itself. Personally, I don't need any change to speak of beyond a new map once in a while and maybe a new game type or two in a season. I'm not really clear on what kind of change the streamers and pros are looking for, but if I had to guess I'd say they're looking for the kind of change that has a label such as "Apex Legends 2," because that's what would drive their content numbers. Five year old games just can't bring people in like new titles can, risky though new titles may be. Can anyone speak to the population of PUBG or Fortnite? Sustaining or declining?

So big names are calling out problems with the game. Are they right or are they wrong? Is it helpful in the long term either way, or is it just another sign of inevitable decline?

8 Replies

  • Fortnite is easy to tell the player population because it’s public and all the player counts are displayed for each mode. They def aren’t declining there, depending on the season they are still hitting several millions active at one given point in time. Pubg is tougher to tell since all we have are steam numbers but that also shows their monthly peaks are about 100k higher than they were this time last year as to where apex is very evidently losing players. 

    apex’s biggest problem imo isn’t just keeping players. It’s that it isn’t getting new players and when they do they quit pretty early on because the new player experience in this game is horrendous. Unless they come up with a system to get new players playing and actually sticking with the game it’s just going to continue slowly bleeding.

    the game doesn’t need an apex 2, but doing what Fortnite does and did might help, instead of just keeping it rolling with apex season whatever maybe it’s time for them to hit it with their own version of apex chapter 2, or apex 2.0. Make some fairly large changes to hero’s, change up the map pool, vault some weapons and introduce some new ones, upgrade servers and it’ll def bring a huge influx of players. But that’s also easy for me to say.

  • @reconzero Hal contradicting himself once again. He wouldn't play ranked if he had to solo q. They had a for money solo q only ranked style league and he whined the whole time and eventually stopped playing it.
    He did the same with poi draft. 6 months ago it was the dumbest thing and rewarded lesser teams. Now? He says they should do it in ranked.
    I can't take him seriously. He sounds like a disgruntled employee most of the time but he's refuses to try another game to stream because he's scared he will become irrelevant.
    The game is almost 6 years old. EA hasn't been able to capture the magic of Fortnite so its doing what most games do......slowly decline. What I see wrong with this are three major things-
    Lack of modes. I will never understand why we cannot have more modes. Warzone and Fortnite both have continuous rotations of modes.
    Matchmaking and similar lobbies. Have similar skill AND playstyles together. Right now it's one good, one bad and one medium together. The good gets mad at both lesser and the bad gets slaughtered. It doesn't make any sense.
    Cheating, especially on PC. Do more like the Linux stuff.
  • RockDokRock's avatar
    RockDokRock
    Seasoned Ace
    8 months ago

    @hayhorYawn, I pay zero attention to "Pros"... historically, from what I've read/seen, they tend to have far too much influence and have no idea the experience 99% of the playerbase has... none. They are irrelevant.

  • Airish85's avatar
    Airish85
    8 months ago

    Imagine playing only the same single map for the full season and still get excited about it like they do in Fortnite...
    The thing with the Fortnite popularity is the community created game modes / Unreal editor.
    For example the Fortnite version of OnlyUp parkour game had bigger or similar daily player numbers as Apex has for a short period of time. 
    By opening up the game for people to make their own games they are able to cater to whatever you feel like. 
    Somedays you might not feel like playing PvP battle royale so there are so many other options to do.

  • hayhor's avatar
    hayhor
    Hero
    8 months ago
    @Airish85 All that gives players more options. Apex has more options. They just don't allow us to pick. Why is mixtape a thing? Why aren't control, gun run and tdm seperate modes?
  • "Options" 😃

    Real options would be to give players all the R5 movement tech maps, Halo gun/map modes (R5 Reloaded), maybe some racing game modes, PvE vs Prowlers swarm survival, Arena maps with zero Q time on Path etc. And the beauty with Fortnite is that the devs dont have to do any of the work on these thanks to the creative modes & unreal editor. 

    Why is it always so serious? Why do I need to sweat it to stay in the SoloQ PvP rat race? I am older than the average player and I play for fun. If I try to fool around ("not locked in") for the fun of it, I get insulted by teammates who expect me to take it seriously and lock in.

    "We don't stop playing because we grow old; we grow old because we stop playing."
    And I stop playing when I am not having fun. 

    But yes I do agree with you. 

  • reconzero's avatar
    reconzero
    Seasoned Ace
    8 months ago
    @Airish85

    "We don't stop playing because we grow old; we grow old because we stop playing."

    I both love and hate that quote at the same time. Do you know where it came from?

    For me it's more: I don't stop playing because I've grown old, but I've stopped playing by the rules or expecting the game to be fun. I've grown old so I make my own fun out of whatever it is the dev tries to feed me.

    My poor teammates.
  • @reconzero
    Its a quote by the Irish playwright George Bernard Shaw.

    Fun can mean many things. Its not necessarily laughing or even smiling while playing. Sometimes its just pure excitement about getting back to the game. One of the reasons why I have only played a handful of bot royale games this season. Apex in its current state does not give me that excitement.

    I am kinda waiting for that excitement to come back while playing other games. With other games I mainly mean PvE. I am quite hesitant on trying out new PvP shooters because since on those skill ceiling is so high. If you have a great aim to begin with youll get quite far. But someone like me who is very much relied on the tactical side its a steep climb to learn a new "ability shooter".

About Apex Legends General Discussion

Discuss the latest news and game information around Apex Legends in the community forums.31,252 PostsLatest Activity: 2 hours ago