Forum Discussion

RMEChief's avatar
RMEChief
Legend
4 years ago

Was BF2042 originally developed as a Hero Shooter?

I have been thinking about this for awhile and after  seeing the info on this previously, I think the theory has legs. 

Based on the Specialists, lack of classes and scoreboard, other missing BF elements, and some of the map designs, it really feels like they were developing towards a Hero Shooter with modes like Hazard Zone and then tried to convert back to traditional BF in the last year. That's why everything feels so rushed and so many core elements are missing.

We play as No-Pats but are on the US or Russian faction. Irish is American but can play on the Russian faction? Boris is Russian and he can play on US faction? Why or how is that possible? It is if they made the Specialists and maps before the factions. Square peg, round hole. 

The whole working remotely for developers is a bogus excuse from EA. With Zoom calls and constant mobbing, dev teams can be just as effective and efficient working remotely. I just think that is a convenient excuse. Most studios have satellite offices anyway. Like how does that prevent a scoreboard, platoons, VOIP, and a server browser from being implemented upon release? We can't even switch teams or squads! There are just so many core BF elements missing it's mind boggling. 

Even most of the map designs are off. It's like they were made for other game modes and hastily made to fit Conquest, Rush, and Breakthrough.

I could go on and on, but the theory makes sense. So why release a half baked game? Earnings calls. They needed the pre-order money in the quarter leading up to the release and couldn't afford to delay it otherwise they would've lost millions in refunds and even more in stock value. 

Thoughts? 

16 Replies

  • kregora's avatar
    kregora
    Seasoned Ace
    4 years ago
    @Adamonic I work that theory for quite some time now.

    For me it started with a "what it ..." and then most of the design decisions make sense.

    Even the fact that there are no anti-vehicle specialists like the classical Battlefield Engineer.

  • Great theory.

    So when was the next battlefield game going to come out? 2024, 2025?

    6 to 7 years after BFV.

  • @AdamonicYeah, we've been pointing this out for the past 3 months. It was an obvious hero shooter failure trying to contend with fortnite and warzone. But in the end, it was Halo that killed the game.

  • snakeeyes00's avatar
    snakeeyes00
    Seasoned Hotshot
    4 years ago

    I think there maybe even more issues, specifically with the frostbite engine.   It was being rebuilt at the same time that they were going Battle Royal mode rather than a typical BF title. With that in mind it would fit that the new frostbite engine (frostbite 4) was not built with a typical BF title in mind and thus why there is so much missing and why there are so many problems.

    If the frostbite engine was designed for one thing then made to be reconfigured for another.......   You see where I'm going.   It could be that everything is being delayed because either Ripple Effect (DICE LA) or DICE themselves have to make major changes to the frostbite engine.  If that is the case summer is optimistic at best for season one.

    Personally I would rather see 2042 get it's promised content for those still playing it, and rebuilt the frostbite engine for a Typical BF title and start development on 2142.  Something that was hinted at 10 years ago with BF4 Final stand DLC.  I mean this is what a lot of people were waiting for ever since BF4 final stand came out.  Then we got BF1 - great game and well done.  Then we got BF5 and I just think that fans were really waiting for the continuation of BF4.  So when 2042 was shown that caused the hype that the BF fans were waiting for.  And then we got this. So disappointing.   I don't know anymore, this is just my opinion,  but with most of the original DICE devs gone I'm not really sure we'll ever see that continuation of BF4 we've been waiting for, or maybe just hoping for. 

About Battlefield 2042 General Discussion

Discuss the latest news and game information around Battlefield 2042 in the community forums.16,182 PostsLatest Activity: 5 days ago