Bots/Portal and Gamemodes
This is going to be a rather long post were I just leave some thoughts on the game after playing for a couple hundred of hours!
Starting with Bots: Personally I think Bots were a mistake. They've been used for XP/Challenge/Unlock farming ever since they've been introduced in 2042 which also leads to Portal being a whole lot of wasted potential.
I don't believe we need Bots! Especially not in Portal. I'd say adding bots was one of the worst things that could have happened to the game.
Portal: Portal could be a good way to incorporate the players/creators who's creativity could deliver us some great extra content in form of new maps. From recreating legendary maps throughout the gaming industry to completely self made ones.
However! Due to the nature of how we enter a match nobody really bothers looking through the server browser to see if there's actually some active servers instead we click on the mode we wanna play and that's it.
A solution? First of all remove Bots. If you give players the tools to farm bots they will do it. Secondly? A new approach to Portal OR matchmaking!
Having a serverbrowser like we do in BF6 right now is kinda like having the keys to a giant empty warehouse. There's lots of space for great things but no one is taking advantage of it.
If the browser would work like it used to in past games where you would search through the available servers (official and player made) to find the maps and modes you like and get rid of the "pick and click matchmaking" there would be a lot more interaction between players. Cheaters would be banned, toxic players kicked and broken content could be disabled.
OR use portal as a tool for creators to create new maps, host fun events for their communitys and nothing more. No unlocks, no challenges and no endless lists of creations no one plays. Include the creators in official matchmaking, take some time to polish and optimize and you got a new map basically for free.
Last point: Gamemodes
What else can we say about Gamemodes other than: WE DON'T NEED MORE!
What we need is a healthy amount of modes that work well on the existing and upcoming maps. There were to many modes in the game even from the beginning. By adding more the only thing that will happen is that the player base will be more and more devided. On top of that you (the devs) open up more and more tasks you need to make sure are working as intended.
The best thing would be to remove some of the existing modes and stop adding more because like i said it splits the community and you just put on more workload. Not to mention that probably nobody is complaining about to few modes.
Who needs to go?
In my opinion you should get rid of: King of the Hill (KOTH), Domination (maybe), Squad-Deathmatch, Team-Deathmatch and Strikepoint (haven't even played it once).
That would leave us with: Breakthrough, Conquest, Domination (maybe), Escalation and Rush.
That way you can focus on optimization of the existing modes and maps and the player base will be closer together.
I really hope you (the devs) will finally start to listen to the players and make some necessary adjustments and additions to the game.
This of course isn't the ultimate solution but I feel like something like this needs to happen.