Several issues have been identified with the OU-Texas game. The score from last year's game is displayed incorrectly at the beginning, and the commentators also report it inaccurately. This error occurs in both quick play and dynasty modes. Additionally, the arrangement of fans alternating between the south and north sides of the stadium is incorrect. In actual games, fans consistently occupy the same sections each year: OU fans are always on the south side, while Texas fans are on the north side. The placement of the bands is also inaccurate. These issues have been noted before.
Additionally, fans are often observed performing the 'horns up' and 'horns down' gestures, symbolic of the OU-Texas rivalry, or Texas-OU, depending on the fanbase. While it is understood that players may not perform these gestures during celebrations, their inclusion among fans is a staple of the game experience, often highlighted by broadcasters who feature children from opposing sides making the signs.
It is acknowledged that the game includes many accurate details, and EA has done well in various aspects. However, for such an iconic event as the Red River Rivalry, it is expected that a greater effort would be made to ensure the game's portrayal is true to its storied history.