Forum Discussion

THEARTISTTLAW's avatar
2 years ago

Roster Editor Ability: Unlock restrictions or refund my purchase

To: EA Designers and Leadership of NCAA 25

From: Disgusted Fans and lifetime purchasers of the game

Issue: Unlimited and Unlocked Player Editor Ability in Dynasty, Create Player as Recruit or Modify attributes of special skills

To Whom It May Concern,

See the comments below from many users lifetime supporters and purchasers of this Game.  

From [edit: email address removed]:  The ability to change or modify rosters and have full control over creating or modifying rosters is appalling.  Please release an update to allow everyone to fully edit their rosters, create recruits, and edit the rosters in dynasty mode and play now mode.  Otherwise, issue me a full refund and I will boycott this game until you make these changes.  

TS

      @kanyeeast13404 days ago
This is literally how I choose to play the game. Me and my kids create ourselves and use small schools to play dynasties. This ruined the entire game for me. These big developers just don’t get it. This is why games like Minecraft are so successful. Let people customize the game to fit their own experience.
 
 
 
I'd rather edit rosters than have real likenesses. imma pass
 
 
I won’t be buying this game for this very reason. I’ll watch YouTubers play. This is stupid EA
 
 
If I can't edit a players rating that's some bs
 
 
 
What I didn't understand- you can create a team- but can’t edit players' names even jersey numbers-  But in “Road to Glory” you can create a player- put him on a team and it’s fine with However I can’t create a player put him on a roster and play offline with that player ..??? What am I missing-
Read more
 
 
This is the reason I won't buy the game. If we can't have full editing control in Dynasty mode, there is absolutely no point in this version. Hard pass.
 
 
This is the only thing that scares me. Idc if we can't make a player that opted out but as long as I can replace him and fully edit that created player I replaced him with I'll be fine. Just don't FORCE me to use some generic QB with 2 shooter sleeves or a white guy named Cordarrel Johnson
 
 
Wish I wouldn't have bought it. Cant edit ratings or even create a player
 
 
 
You can do it in Madden but not NCAA that's stupid
 
Will we be able to edit player ratings/attributes? I wanna see if a 99 OVR demigod QB can take a crummy college to stardom
 
 
 
 
Honestly, it’s not worth buying MFs that can still teleport to interception and so on. I purchased this game for Dynasty, exported my draft class and we can’t even do that. I’m curious as to how much money they will be losing or missing out on because of this
 
 
I get if we can’t change their bodies and looks why can’t we adjust ratings or change throwing styles that’s outright dumb….
 
 
 
This is weak... I just tried to create myself as a QB for my dynasty, and I couldn't even do that... Not to mention I'm playing with UNLV, and our 2 potential starting QBs aren't even in the game... One of the generic QBs wears #4, but so does my RB... I couldn't even change their jersey numbers!
 
 
 
That’s so stupid hopefully they can try to change that so we can edit its rosters but when is Team Builder coming out?
 
 
This cant be we can only pray this isn't real this doesn’t make any sense why wouldn’t we be able to change accessories or ratings

8 Replies

  • DANGERGOOSE1's avatar
    DANGERGOOSE1
    Seasoned Veteran
    2 years ago
    @THEARTISTTLAW I never cared about having real players in the game. Give the ability to edit numbers and ratings of recruits in dynasty this is a must have feature and are no legal ramifications to this (not talking about editing NIL players).
  • We should be able to edit recruiting classes and fictional recruits in dynasty.. smh

  • @THEARTISTTLAW ive waited YEARS to bring my madden draft classes into college football. this RUINS the game for me. there is no reason we cannot edit recruits. at the MINIMUM we should have full customization besides the names if it is really that big of an issue
  • I will not be purchasing until:

    1 - coach mode ala NCAA 14 is implemented

    2 - full player customization in dynasty is added

    3 - add a recruit in dynasty

    4 - sim engine is fixed 

  • The lack of recruit creating/editing in Dynasty Mode is a big issue for a substantial number of people.  Has EA addressed, or commented on, the absence of this feature in any way?  It would be nice for someone from EA to acknowledge the lack of this feature, and say if it's something they are considering adding to NCAA 25 via patch or if that is off the table until '26 comes out.  Those that are looking for this feature would really like to hear something from them.

  • DANGERGOOSE1's avatar
    DANGERGOOSE1
    Seasoned Veteran
    2 years ago

    I got a refund from Xbox a couple days ago. I was going to try and enjoy it for what I could get out of it but dynasty has 0 longevity without ability to edit ratings of new recruits. My QB that threw for 4000 yards 40 TDs and 4 INTs only went up from 79 to 81 overall, and to top it off my new incoming freshman QB was assigned #21 that I couldn't change. That plus the scheduling bugs made the game unenjoyable to me.

    If you're going to do Play Now I guess the game is fine as on field gameplay is great. But to me a football game needs more than on field gameplay to be a good game, especially when dynasty is one of the core modes of the game and was advertised as such. This game literally has a setting in dynasty setup and in dynasty settings that says player edit permissions and the description says it enables specifically RATINGS EDITING for either commissioner only, for every user, or off. So it's a setting that's in the game that just plain doesn't work.

  • hkyplr11's avatar
    hkyplr11
    New Adventurer
    2 years ago

    That setting makes me wonder if the devs meant for editing to be in the game and the lawyers made them pull it last minute. Would explain why there’s tons of bugs. 

About College Football 25 General Discussion

Join the community on the forums and talk about your passion for EA SPORTS™ College Football 25.2,561 PostsLatest Activity: 2 months ago