Forum Discussion

coastereight's avatar
12 months ago

We Need Formation Subs. Retire the Depth Chart from 25 Years Ago.

An OLB is not the same in a 4-3 as a 3-4. In a 4-2-5 an OLB is probably actually a weak side linebacker but could also be a rover, which this game forces as a SS. The problem is if you want to be multiple on defense, the depth chart doesn't translate between a 4-2-5 and a 4-3 or a 3-4. Similarly, a 3-4 OLB might be a 4-3 DE.

It's really difficult to scheme on defense when I'm locked into a depth chart that seems to be based on a 4-3 defense. The 4-3 hasn't been common in football for years. The 4-2-5, 3-3-5, 3-3-5 tite, etc. are not conducive to how the depth charts in this game work. Maybe my rover isn't a strong safety. Maybe I have a linebacker that plays it better but I want to shift into a different set. That can get completely messed up because the way depth charts work is 4-3 or 3-4 based with no formation subs. A majority of the time, this isn't how defense work anymore.

I'll add, they should consider taking it as far as play subs, because if I have a coverage linebacker playing rover and a speed rush linebacker playing viper in a 4-2-5, guess which one is rushing the passer?

6 Replies

  • There were actually formation subs in the EA NCAA Football series back in the 2000’s.

    We also had O lineman that blocked for a full second prior to releasing to set up a screen block. We also had an option pitch that wasn’t trash like we have in 2025.

    We used to press A to hand off the ball on the option since EA’s Bill Walsh College football circa 1992. So for 30 years I’ve been pressing A to hand off the ball on the tripe option in EA’s NCAA football. Now these insufferable clowns think they’re a trend setter by changing things for the sake of change. Not only do they change how the handoff input works, I.e. do NOTHING to hand off the ball instead of tapping A like we’ve been doing for THREE DECADES, there is no SETTINGS option to change it back to Tap A to hand off the ball. 

    The absolute hubris involved in changing how the option hand off works would make Caligula blush. Change for the sake of change. So stunning. So brave. 

    Please add in a settings option for the “Classic option” so that tapping A hands off the ball. 

  • tm219's avatar
    tm219
    Rising Adventurer
    12 months ago

    The formation sub comment makes sense 

    Not sure why it matters that a handoff mechanic changed to begin with, seems like just something to deal with but also doesn’t seem to make sense in a post about formation subs. 

  • Zhukov211's avatar
    Zhukov211
    12 months ago

    @Sgt_Sparrowhawk

    Im not amused by your shameful and disturbing attempt to shut down open discourse in a …. DISCUSSION FORUM…. .

    How dare I speak my mind. 

    Several features that used to be in the franchise or that use to actually work in the franchise aren’t available or no longer work as intended in 2025.

    It’s seems some of these core features of the franchise were simply left out, were needlessly changed for the sake of change, or are simply broken. 

    - Custom Playbooks and Custom Audibles being available for Dynasty and for online play. This was a thing up until 2014. Why in the world is this not available in 2025? 

    - Formation subs. Could be saved in your playbook and would work in online play without any player action needed between plays. Not so in 2025.

    - Pressing A to hand off the ball in the option. This existed from 1992-2014. Was changed in 2025 because???

    Sorry but not sorry. When a team fails so completely at their job, when aspects of the game are needlessly changed for no other plausible reason than being changed simply for the sake of change, and when great features of the franchise disappear for no plausible reason other than being additional work for the Devs, this needs to be called out. 

  • JackDaddy16's avatar
    JackDaddy16
    Seasoned Vanguard
    12 months ago
    @coastereight But they claim the game was made by "passionate college football fans".

    If they are passionate fans then I'm definitely an all-knowing, crazed college football addict.

About College Football 25 General Discussion

Join the community on the forums and talk about your passion for EA SPORTS™ College Football 25.2,561 PostsLatest Activity: 2 months ago