It sounds insane, but I can confirm that on my gaming PC (7800X3D, 32GB RAM, RTX 4070 Ti Super, Win 11 Pro, 4TB SSD), running on an HDD (an old WD3003FZEX) did significantly improve the sound issues (there are other problems caused by the slow load times though), compared to running on an SSD (Kingston SFYRD).
On my gaming laptop with much lower spec hardware (i7, 16GB RAM, RTX 2070, Win 10 Home), I used an external SSD (Crucial X9 Pro) and never had any sound issues. So it isn't only using an SSD that causes the sound problem, but a combination of SSD plus higher end configuration.
As a starting point, on my gaming PC, with the game installed on an SSD and set to Ultra graphics settings, I observe these issues:
- The loading intro video lags, and the sound crackles and skips.
- Varric's initial narrative slide introducing the bar scene has severe video lag and sound crackling.
- Minor sound crackling and popping for ambient dialogue Minrathous.
To test on the same gaming PC, I copied the game to my HDD and then ran the EA App installer to verify the files and launch the game. On the HDD, with Ultra graphics settings:
- The loading intro video played without any video lag or crackling.
- Varric's initial narrative slide introducing the bar scene played with no video lag and with only minor crackling on a couple of words.
- There was no crackling for ambient dialogue in Minrathous.
- However! The load times are atrocious, and texture and model loading in-game is very slow (e.g., sprinting through Minrathous means that NPCs don't load before I've run past them, and if I stand still in a busy location, then I can observe the NPCs popping into place).
As mentioned in my other post on this thread, the sound issues are virtually eliminated outside of Varric's narrative slides when the game is installed on my SSD and when I select High graphics options and then turn textures and terrain quality down to Medium. I also have less video lag in Varric's narrative slides with those custom graphics settings.
ETA: just for giggles, since I didn't have issues using the Crucial X9 SSD external drive on my laptop, I swapped over to test the same drive on my gaming PC. Same sound and video issues on the intro video as with the Kingston SSD. So the brand of the drive and the connection type (USB-C versus PCIe) aren't a culprit.
ETA2: tested the game on a friend's PC, they have a virtually identical system to mine, same mobo, except: slightly lower AMD processor, slightly less beefy GPU, and smaller SSD. (7600X, 32GB RAM, RTX 4070 Super, Win 11 Home, 2TB SSD) No issues whatsoever. It runs better on Ultra than mine runs on mostly Medium settings. It's a lil frustrating to feel like I'm playing on a potato quality machine when it should be able to run Ultra easily.
EA_Illiumyou were previously active on this thread, can you please make sure that the team is aware of how the type of drive seems to affect this issue for higher end PCs? Also, would you be willing to update this thread and let us know whether the team is working on this and expects to be able to fix it? This is a long-running issue that hasn't had any update for quite some time. Thank you!